Lubinpla

Four-Ball Wear Scar Test: When a Smaller Scar Is Not Better

Summary

ASTM D4172-25 measures wear scar diameter on steel balls in sliding contact. A smaller scar ranks better only at identical test conditions: load, temperature and time. As of 2026-10-23, D4172-25 is the active edition. The difference must also exceed the method's repeatability, and the scar rates neither extreme-pressure capacity nor rolling bearing life.

  • ASTM D4172-25 is the active edition of the four-ball wear method for lubricating fluids, last updated on 2025-12-10 (ASTM, 2025).

  • One patent describes a D4172 run as 1200 rpm for 60 minutes under a force of 40 kg at 75 °C (US 11180710 B2, 2021).

  • Another patent reports scars "according to ASTM D4172" at about 1450 rpm and about 300 N, measured after 1 hour and after 2 hours (US 11312918 B2, 2022).

  • ISO 20623:2017, the international four-ball method for EP and anti-wear properties under European conditions, was last reviewed and confirmed in 2023 (ISO, 2023).

This answer covers lubricating fluids tested on the four-ball wear machine under ASTM D4172 or a similar wear procedure. It does not cover greases, which have their own method in ASTM D2266, or the weld point and load-wear index from four-ball extreme-pressure tests. It sets no pass limit for any product specification.

What does the ASTM D4172 four-ball wear scar test measure, and how?

The ASTM D4172 four-ball wear scar test measures the average wear scar diameter that a lubricating fluid allows on three stationary steel balls while a fourth ball slides against them under load. ASTM describes the scope as "a procedure for making a preliminary evaluation of the anti-wear properties of fluid lubricants in sliding contact by means of the Four-Ball Wear Test Machine" (ASTM D4172-25, clause 1.1).

The three lower balls are clamped in a cup and covered with the test fluid. The top ball is pressed into them and rotated. One patent summarizes a D4172 run as rotating a steel ball atop three clamped balls at 1200 rpm for 60 minutes under a force of 40 kg at 75 °C (US 11180710 B2, 2021). After the run, the scars on the three lower balls are measured and averaged, and the average scar size is "reported as the result of the test" (US 3997454 A, 1976).

ASTM states the purpose in its significance section: the method "can be used to determine the relative wear preventive properties of lubricating fluids in sliding contact under the prescribed test conditions" (ASTM D4172-25, clause 5.1). Two phrases set the limits. Relative means the result ranks fluids against each other, not against a machine. Prescribed test conditions means the ranking holds only for the load, speed, temperature and time used.

Internationally, ISO 20623:2017 specifies four-ball procedures for "the extreme pressure (EP) and anti-wear properties" of liquid lubricants and greases (ISO 20623:2017, abstract).

When are two four-ball wear scar results comparable?

Two four-ball wear scar results are comparable only when both runs used the same method and edition, the same load, speed, temperature and duration, and the same averaging of the three lower balls. The ASTM grease method gives the reason: "if the test conditions are changed the relative ratings may be different" (ASTM D2266-23, clause 5.1).

One patent describes D4172 at 1200 rpm, 40 kg, 75 °C and 60 minutes (US 11180710 B2, 2021). The other reports results "according to ASTM D4172" at about 1450 rpm and about 300 N, with scars measured after 1 hour and after 2 hours (US 11312918 B2, 2022). Both cite the same method, yet their scars cannot be compared. The first patent also runs the test at several temperatures to find where an antiwear additive becomes active (US 11180710 B2, 2021), so temperature alone can move the result.

D4172 runs "under the prescribed test conditions", so a report that cites the method at other settings describes a modified run; ask the laboratory whether it ran the prescribed conditions (ASTM D4172-25, clause 5.1).

Before you compare, ask each laboratory for the method and edition, the load, speed, temperature and duration, the number of runs and the individual ball readings. If any of these differ, treat the two numbers as separate experiments. A site trial needs the same habit of checking validity before interpreting; a guide on how to tell whether a failed plant trial was valid at all walks through it.

How do you read four-ball wear scar results?

Read a four-ball wear scar result in order: confirm that the conditions match, check whether the difference exceeds the precision limit, and only then rank the smaller scar as better wear protection under those conditions. ASTM says D4172 determines "relative wear preventive properties" (ASTM D4172-25, clause 5.1), so every row below is a ranking decision, not an estimate of field life.

The table below sets out what a four-ball wear scar result means and what to do next with it.

Four-ball wear scar result

Meaning

Action

Smaller scar, same conditions, difference larger than the repeatability limit in the D4172 precision section (ASTM D6300-26, clause 5.2)

Better wear protection in sliding steel contact under those conditions

Accept as a ranking; confirm in the application or a closer bench test

Difference within the repeatability limit

No demonstrated difference

Treat as a tie; run repeats or decide on other properties

Results at different load, temperature or time (US 11312918 B2, 2022)

Separate experiments; ratings may change with conditions (ASTM D2266-23, clause 5.1)

Ask for a side-by-side run under one set of conditions

Grease run by the fluid method instead of ASTM D2266

Not a grease wear result; D4172 refers greases to D2266 (ASTM D4172-25, clause 1.1)

Request ASTM D2266 data for the grease

Small scar where the need is extreme-pressure load capacity

Says nothing about weld point or load-wear index (ASTM D2783-25, clause 1.1)

Ask for ASTM D2783 for fluids or D2596 for greases

Of these rows, the second changes a decision most often. When two four-ball wear scars differ by less than the repeatability limit, the smaller one has not been shown better, even if a supplier's pass limit happens to fall between the two numbers.

Read the third and fourth rows as requests for better data, not as results. Neither number can be ranked until the run is repeated under the matching method and conditions.

How much four-ball wear scar difference is within test repeatability?

A four-ball wear scar difference smaller than the repeatability limit in the precision section of ASTM D4172 is within test scatter for one laboratory. A difference smaller than the reproducibility limit is within scatter between laboratories. ASTM D6300 states that "Repeatability and reproducibility are defined in the precision section of every Committee D02 test method" (ASTM D6300-26, clause 5.2), and D4172 is a Committee D02 method (ASTM, 2025). Take the limits from the edition the laboratory ran.

Repeatability covers two results from the same operator, apparatus and laboratory on the same fluid. Reproducibility covers results from different laboratories, so it is the wider limit, and the one to use when you set a supplier's data sheet against your own laboratory's result. ASTM E177 explains what such limits are: "A statement of precision is not intended to exhibit values that can be exactly duplicated in every user's laboratory." (ASTM E177-26a, clause 4.2.1). The limits describe typical scatter; they promise nothing for a single run.

The practical rule is short. Subtract one average scar diameter from the other. If the difference is below repeatability for one laboratory, or below reproducibility for two, report no difference.

Where a specification limit applies, ASTM D3244 offers a way for supplier and buyer to agree an acceptance limit (AL), and it "requires the AL be determined prior to actual commencement of testing" (ASTM D3244-24, clause 4.3). Agreeing the limit and the number of runs before testing removes the temptation to rerun until a result passes.

Why does a smaller four-ball wear scar not predict bearing or gear life?

A smaller four-ball wear scar does not predict bearing or gear life because the test runs sliding point contact between steel balls. Ball bearings run rolling point contact, and gears and roller bearings typically run line contact. The method itself says: "No attempt has been made to correlate this test with balls in rolling contact." (ASTM D4172-25, clause 5.1). The grease method goes further: "No correlation has been established between the four-ball wear test and field service." (ASTM D2266-23, clause 5.1).

ASTM leaves the transfer to the user, who "should determine to his own satisfaction whether results of this test procedure correlate with field performance or other bench test machines" (ASTM D4172-25, clause 5.1). A lubrication engineer makes the same point about geometry. The rig combines point contact with sliding, and "This combination is rarely observed in machinery" (Britton, Precision Lubrication, accessed 2026). In his account, the most severe machine contacts are line contact with sliding, as in journal bearings, or point contact with rolling, as in ball bearings (Britton, Precision Lubrication, accessed 2026).

Field wear also depends on what the four-ball test fixes or leaves out: particles and water in the oil, film thickness at operating viscosity, surface finish, misalignment and load cycles. That suggests the scar is best read as evidence that an antiwear chemistry is active in boundary sliding at the test temperature, which is how one patent uses it (US 11180710 B2, 2021), and not as a life rating for a bearing or gear.

How does the four-ball wear test differ from the four-ball EP test?

The four-ball wear test runs one constant load and reports the scar diameter, while the four-ball extreme-pressure (EP) test raises the load in steps to find a weld point and a load-wear index. ASTM D2783 "covers the determination of the load-carrying properties of lubricating fluids", and its two determinations are the "Load-wear index (formerly Mean-Hertz load)" and the "Weld point by means of the four-ball extreme-pressure (EP) tester" (ASTM D2783-25, clause 1.1). Its purpose differs from that of D4172 as well: D2783, "used for specification purposes, differentiates between lubricating fluids having low, medium, and high level of extreme-pressure properties" (ASTM D2783-25, clause 5.1).

The two tests answer different questions. A wear scar shows how much the lubricant limits wear at a moderate constant load. The EP test finds the load at which the film collapses and the balls weld. Because they measure different things, one fluid can rank differently in the two.

ASTM makes the separation explicit for greases: the wear method "cannot be used to differentiate between Extreme Pressure (EP) and Non-Extreme Pressure (Non-EP) Greases" (ASTM D2266-23, clause 5.1). For greases, the EP counterpart of D2783 is ASTM D2596, as D2783 notes in its scope (ASTM D2783-25, clause 1.2).

ISO 20623:2017 covers both determinations in one international method for "the extreme pressure (EP) and anti-wear properties" of lubricants (ISO 20623:2017, abstract). A report that cites ISO 20623 should therefore say which determination produced the number.

Why do published sources disagree on what a four-ball wear scar shows?

Published sources disagree on what a four-ball wear scar shows because patents use it as a pass or fail grade, while the ASTM methods describe it as a relative ranking with no pass limit in their public scope. A 1976 patent states: "The smaller the wear scar, the better the EP characteristics of the test lubricant." It goes on to set a limit: the lubricant "must not have a Four-Ball scar of greater than 0.6 mm, and preferably not greater than 0.5 mm" (US 3997454 A, 1976). A 2021 patent says "average wear scar results of 0.6 mm and under are considered passing results" (US 11180710 B2, 2021).

ASTM treats wear and EP as separate properties, measured by D4172 and D2783 (ASTM D4172-25; ASTM D2783-25), and the wear method calls itself "a preliminary evaluation" (ASTM D4172-25, clause 1.1). The 1976 wording, that a smaller wear scar means better EP characteristics, conflicts with that separation. The 0.6 mm figure is a patent's chosen threshold, not a limit stated in the method's scope.

The disagreement comes from purpose. A patent needs a measurable threshold to show that an invention works, so it picks one, sometimes at conditions of its own choosing (US 11312918 B2, 2022). A test method leaves limits to specifications. When a data sheet says a four-ball wear scar "passes", ask whose limit it was, at which conditions, and whether it comes from a specification you are bound to or from the supplier's own target.

Common mistakes when comparing four-ball wear scars

The common mistakes when comparing four-ball wear scars come from reading the number apart from its conditions, its scatter or its purpose. Five recur in supplier comparisons:

  1. Setting a data sheet result against your own laboratory's result without the reproducibility limit, which is the one that applies between laboratories (ASTM D6300-26, clause 5.2).

  2. Comparing scars run at different loads or durations. One patent reports 1 hour and 2 hour scars for the same fluids (US 11312918 B2, 2022).

  3. Reading 0.6 mm as a method limit. The figure appears in patents as a pass level (US 11180710 B2, 2021); it is not a D4172 requirement.

  4. Using a wear scar to choose an EP gear oil. Wear and EP are separate four-ball methods (ASTM D2783-25, clause 5.1), and gear oils have the FZG test, run on real test gears, which screens "the scuffing load capacity of oils used to lubricate spur and helical (parallel axis) gear units" (ASTM D5182-26, clause 5.1).

  5. Reading one run as a result. ASTM E177 says a precision statement gives guidelines on "the magnitude of variability that can be expected between test results" (ASTM E177-26a, clause 4.2.1); a single run cannot show where in that spread it fell.

Each mistake asks a ranking test for a verdict it was not designed to give. The fix is the same order of work every time: confirm the conditions, apply the precision limit, then interpret the four-ball wear scar.

What to use alongside the four-ball wear scar test

Use the four-ball wear scar test alongside an EP test, a test closer to the application geometry and in-service evidence, because the wear scar alone ranks sliding wear at one condition. The table below matches each question to a method.

Question

Method

What it adds

EP load capacity of a fluid

ASTM D2783-25 four-ball EP

Weld point and load-wear index (ASTM D2783-25, clause 1.1)

Wear protection of a grease

ASTM D2266-23 four-ball wear

Grease wear scar in sliding steel-on-steel contact (ASTM D2266-23, clause 1.1)

Scuffing in spur and helical gears

ASTM D5182-26 FZG

Scuffing load capacity on test gears (ASTM D5182-26, clause 5.1)

International four-ball data

ISO 20623:2017

EP and anti-wear results under European conditions (ISO 20623:2017)

For gear oil selection, the row that matters most is the third. The FZG test runs real test gears, so it sits closer to a gearbox than the four-ball rig, although ASTM notes it "may not directly relate to scuffing performance observed with spiral bevel on hypoid gearing" (ASTM D5182-26, clause 5.2).

Whatever the result, record the conditions, the number of runs and the precision limit, so the next reviewer can check the comparison. Lubinpla, an applied AI company for specialty chemicals, evaluates a test result from the customer's own reports by first checking that the test conditions and repeats were valid, then returns one cited document for the user to review.

Key takeaways

  • ASTM D4172-25 ranks fluids by average wear scar in sliding steel contact at one set of conditions; it is a preliminary screen.

  • Compare two scars only at the same load, speed, temperature, duration and edition.

  • A difference inside the repeatability or reproducibility limit is a tie, not a ranking.

  • Pass limits such as 0.6 mm appear in patents, not in the method's public scope.

  • Wear scar, EP weld point and FZG scuffing answer different questions; ask for the one that matches the failure you fear.

Related posts