Lubinpla

Adhesive Bond Failure: What to Send the Manufacturer

Summary

Preparing an adhesive bond failure for the manufacturer takes 5 steps: preserve the part, keep controls, record the lot, log surface prep and cure, and photograph the failure. Then label every fact as observed, reported or unconfirmed. The package fits industrial bonds on metals and plastics; programs with their own nonconformance procedures add records to it.

  • ISO 10365:2022 specifies the designations for the main failure patterns of bonded assemblies and applies to all mechanical tests on a bonded assembly, whatever the adherends and adhesive (ISO 10365:2022).

  • ASTM D5573 classifies failure modes in bonded fiber-reinforced-plastic joints by visual observation without magnification, and it does not address whether a given failure mode is acceptable (ASTM D5573-99(2019)).

  • In a 2025 case, a laboratory compared a unit that detached in service with a second failed unit from the same supplier, a good unit from a second supplier and adhesive from an earlier batch by SEM and FTIR, and still reported "no irrefutable proof" of the cause (C2MI, 2025).

  • The same laboratory notes that FTIR penetration depth runs from under 1 µm to about 10 µm depending on the technique, which may miss the finest details of surface composition (C2MI, 2025).

This package covers bonded joints in industrial assembly, such as structural adhesives, tapes and sealants on metals and plastics, returned to the adhesive manufacturer for investigation. Aerospace, medical device and automotive programs with their own nonconformance procedures add records to this list, and a failure that injured someone may need an independent laboratory before the parts leave your hands.

What do you need before sending an adhesive bond failure to the manufacturer?

Before sending an adhesive bond failure to the manufacturer, have five things in hand: the failed part with both fracture surfaces; a control part, meaning an unfailed part bonded from the same lot, or unused adhesive from that lot; the lot and storage records; the surface preparation and cure record; and dated photos of the failure.

The failed part alone rarely settles the cause. In one published case, a contract laboratory investigating thermostat screens that had come away from their ABS housings analyzed a unit that detached at the customer's site, a unit built with the same supplier's screen and adhesive assembly, a unit with a second supplier's assembly, and adhesive from a batch of the previous year (C2MI, 2025). Even with scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), its first conclusion reads: "Unfortunately, there is no irrefutable proof." (C2MI, 2025).

What stayed open in that case were process questions, not laboratory ones: how long the protective film was off before the screen was placed, the humidity and temperature on the assembly line, a change in cleaning products, and a change in storage or shipping conditions (C2MI, 2025). The answers sit in your records, not in the failed part.

How do you prepare an adhesive bond failure package step by step?

The package takes five steps, and each one produces a piece of what the manufacturer receives.

  1. Preserve the failed part. Stop handling the bond area, keep both halves, and put each half in its own clean, labeled bag.

  2. Keep controls, the references the laboratory compares against. Set aside an unfailed part bonded from the same adhesive lot, unused adhesive from that lot and, if you have one, a part from an earlier lot that performed well. Before shipping unused adhesive, take the UN number and transport class from SDS section 14, then pack and label under the mode's transport rule (Regulation 1907/2006, Annex II).

  3. Record the lot and storage. Write down the adhesive lot number, the expiry or manufacture date, the date the container was opened and how it was stored.

  4. Log surface preparation and cure. Record the substrate lot, every preparation step, the time between preparation and bonding, the mix ratio and the actual cure time, temperature and humidity.

  5. Photograph and name the failure mode. Photograph both surfaces with a scale, and describe where the bond separated in standard terms.

Then label every fact as observed, reported or unconfirmed, with who supplied it and when. A cure temperature read from the oven log is observed; a line supervisor's memory of it is reported. The labels come from general complaint practice. For the full structure of an escalation to a manufacturer, see What Manufacturers Need From a Distributor Complaint Escalation.

How should you preserve a failed adhesive bond before shipping it?

Preserve a failed adhesive bond by leaving both fracture surfaces exactly as they came apart: no cleaning, no wiping, no fitting the halves back together, and no tape, marker or fingerprints on the bond area. The fracture surfaces are the main evidence of where the bond separated, and every touch adds something that was not there when it failed.

Contamination found later is hard to date. In the C2MI investigation, SEM found gypsum, cardboard and hair on the detached adhesive, and the laboratory "could not determine whether the particles were partly responsible for the adhesion failure, or whether they were symptoms, adhering to the adhesive after it detached from the housing." (C2MI, 2025). It added that some particles "might even have deposited on the sample in the laboratory." (C2MI, 2025). Careful handling from the moment of failure narrows that doubt.

Practical handling:

  • Wear clean gloves and hold parts well away from the bond line.

  • Bag each half on its own, then pack both in a rigid box so the surfaces cannot rub.

  • Keep release liners, protective films and any spacer or tape removed during assembly. In a second C2MI case, the replacement protective film one supplier fitted to its tape carried far less silicone release coating than the other supplier's original film (C2MI, 2025).

  • Label each bag with the part identifier, the date and place of failure, and who has handled it.

Which lot, shelf life and storage records does the adhesive manufacturer need?

The manufacturer needs the adhesive lot or batch number, the manufacture or expiry date, the date the container was opened, and the storage temperature from receipt to use. For a two-part adhesive, give the lot printed on each component's container.

Shelf life is a figure with conditions attached. One maker's technical data sheet for a two-part epoxy gives "a shelf life of 15 months when stored in its original container" and says to store it at 15 to 27 °C or refrigerate it for maximum shelf life (3M DP-460EG TDS, 2019). An adhesive decanted into another container, or stored outside the stated range, falls outside the conditions that figure assumes, even if the label date has not passed.

Report the storage you can document: a warehouse temperature log is observed, while "kept in the stores room" is reported.

Two more records help the manufacturer place the lot in its own history. First, the quantity of that lot still unopened, so it can be held and tested against the maker's retained sample. Second, the lot of an earlier delivery that bonded well, if you have one: the C2MI investigation used adhesive "from a batch from the previous year" as its reference (C2MI, 2025). Do the same for the substrate. In that case, the requester had traced the failures to screen and adhesive assemblies made at one supplier during a specific period (C2MI, 2025).

What surface preparation and cure conditions should you record for a bond failure?

Record each surface preparation step as it was done on the failed parts, and the cure conditions the bond actually saw: time, temperature and humidity as measured, not as written in the work instruction.

For surface preparation, name the procedure you follow and any change to it. ISO 17212:2012 describes the usual surface preparation procedures for metals and plastics before bonding, for laboratory evaluation or production (ISO 17212:2012). Record the cleaner and its lot, any abrasion or primer step, and the time between preparation and bonding. If you run a water-break test, include the result: ASTM F22 describes it as a go or no-go check for hydrophobic films that "may interfere with subsequent surface treatments such as priming, conversion coating, anodizing, plating, or adhesive bonding" on metal surfaces (ASTM F22-21).

For mixing and cure, record:

  • The mix ratio and how it was dispensed: by cartridge, meter-mix or hand.

  • The time from mixing to joint closure, against the work life on the data sheet.

  • Cure time and temperature before the part was handled or loaded. One epoxy data sheet states that the adhesive "will cure in 24 hours at room temperature" and that heat accelerates the cure (3M DP-460EG TDS, 2019).

  • Shop temperature and relative humidity on the bonding day, with the instrument used.

  • Any change in cleaning chemicals, liners or operators near the failure date.

How do you check the adhesive bond failure package before sending it?

Run the package through eight checks before sending it, from both failed surfaces to the label on each fact. A package that passes all eight lets the manufacturer's laboratory start work. Each failed check costs at least one more exchange, and lost evidence may not be recoverable.

The table below shows whether the adhesive bond failure package is ready to send.

Check

Pass

Fail and what to do

Failed part

Both surfaces untouched, each half bagged and labeled

Surfaces wiped or handled: say so in the package

Control part

Unfailed part bonded from the same adhesive lot

None kept: bond one now and mark it as made after the failure

Unused adhesive

Same lot, within shelf life, quantity stated

Lot used up: send the nearest lot and mark it as a different lot

Storage record

Temperature from receipt to use, documented

No log: report what is known and mark it reported

Substrate and surface prep

Substrate lot and each prep step as done

Steps unknown: ask the line, or mark them unconfirmed

Cure conditions

Measured time, temperature and humidity

Only the instruction known: state it as the instruction

Failure photos

Both surfaces, with scale, mode named

No scale: rephotograph before shipping

Fact labels

Every fact observed, reported or unconfirmed, with source and date

Unlabeled facts: label them; do not delete them

The control part is the row most often missing, and it is the one that lets the laboratory compare like with like. When time is short, fix it first. Mark any check you cannot pass, with the reason, in the package instead of holding the package back.

Lubinpla's HQ escalation decision writes the technical support request that travels with this package: every fact carries a source and a date, and observed, reported and unconfirmed facts stay apart, so the manufacturer can start without asking again.

Common mistakes when reporting an adhesive bond failure

The most common mistakes are destroying the evidence, sending no reference, writing a conclusion as a fact, and leaving out the process record. Each one forces the manufacturer to ask back, and some cannot be undone.

  • Cleaning or reassembling the failed part. A wiped surface no longer shows what was at the interface when it separated.

  • Sending one half. The two fracture surfaces together show where the bond line gave way; one half shows only part of it.

  • Sending no control. Without an unfailed part or unused adhesive from the same lot, the laboratory cannot tell a lot problem from a process problem.

  • Writing a failure pattern as a cause. "Adhesive failure" names where the joint separated, not why. ASTM D5573 notes that it "does not address the acceptability of any specific failure mode" (ASTM D5573-99(2019)).

  • Reporting the work instruction as what happened. A cure schedule from the instruction is not a measured cure.

Frequently asked questions

How do you photograph and name the adhesive failure mode?

Photograph both fracture surfaces square on, with a ruler or scale in the frame and even lighting, then add close-ups of any area that looks different. Name the pattern with the terms of ISO 10365:2022, which gives designations and diagrams for the main failure patterns of bonded assemblies (ISO 10365:2022), and estimate the share of each pattern by area. For fiber-reinforced plastics, ASTM D5573 classifies modes such as adhesive, cohesive and fiber-tear failure by eye, without magnification (ASTM D5573-99(2019)).

Can you ship unused adhesive from the same lot to the manufacturer?

Yes, once you have asked the manufacturer what it needs and checked the safety data sheet. Take the UN number and transport class from SDS section 14, then pack and label the adhesive under the rule for the transport mode: ADR for road, the IMDG Code for sea and the ICAO Technical Instructions for air (Regulation 1907/2006, Annex II), and in the US the Hazardous Materials Regulations, 49 CFR Parts 171 to 180 (eCFR 2026). Have a person trained for that rule prepare the shipment, as the US rule requires for hazmat employees (49 CFR 172.704), or use your carrier's dangerous goods service.

Does the failure pattern show whether the adhesive was at fault?

No, not on its own. A failure pattern describes where the joint separated; the cause can still lie in the adhesive, the substrate, the surface preparation, the cure or the load. That is why the package pairs the failed part with controls and process records. ASTM D907-15(2023) collects the standard terminology of adhesives, which helps both sides use the same words (ASTM D907-15(2023)).

Should you analyze the failed bond yourself before sending it?

Ask the manufacturer first. Its laboratory may want the surfaces untouched, and some methods are limited in what they can see: the C2MI laboratory notes that, with exceptions, a composition difference of less than 5% will be very difficult to detect by FTIR (C2MI, 2025).

Related posts