ASTM D1748 Humidity Cabinet Results: What Pass and Fail Predict
Summary
ASTM D1748-24 rates rust dots on coated steel panels after set humidity cabinet hours. A pass ranks similar preservatives but cannot predict storage life. As of 2026-10-29, D1748-24 is the active edition. It sets no exposure hours and leaves the interpretation of results to the governing specification (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.4), so both must be fixed before the test.
ASTM D1748-24 is the active edition of the humidity cabinet method for metal preservatives, last updated on 2024-11-06 (ASTM, 2024).
A cabinet built to ASTM D1748 holds 48.9 °C ±1 °C and turns the panel rack at 0.33 ± 0.03 rpm (Ayalytical, accessed 2026).
The 1993 text of MIL-PRF-16173E sets, for grades 2, 3, 4 and 5, a minimum of 30 days in the humidity cabinet and allows no more than three rust dots, none larger than 1 mm (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993).
JIS K 2246:2026, revised on 2026-01-20, has its own humidity cabinet test method for rust preventive oils (JSA, 2026).
This answer covers metal preservatives and rust preventive oils tested on steel panels in the ASTM D1748 humidity cabinet. It does not cover salt spray, condensation or in-package tests, vapor corrosion inhibitor products, or rust tests of lubricants in contact with water. It gives no storage life in months for any product.
What does ASTM D1748 measure and how are the panels prepared?
ASTM D1748 measures how well a metal preservative keeps coated steel panels from rusting in a heated humidity cabinet. Before exposure, the panels are cleaned, abraded, coated, drained and hung. ASTM defines the scope: "This test method covers the evaluation of the rust-preventive properties of metal preservatives under conditions of high humidity." (ASTM D1748-24, clause 1.1). The significance section then narrows the use to "measuring the relative abilities of metal preservatives to prevent the rusting of steel panels under conditions of high humidity" (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.1).
An equipment maker sums up the sequence: steel panels "are prepared to a prescribed surface finish, dipped in the test oil, allowed to drain" and then suspended in a cabinet at 48.9 °C (120 °F) and a high relative humidity (Ascott Analytical, accessed 2026). Another maker's cabinet built to D1748 holds 48.9 °C ±1 °C, turns a rack of up to 33 panels at 0.33 ± 0.03 rpm and offers an optional timer that opens the cover for 15 minutes and 5 minutes each weekday, as the method requires (Ayalytical, accessed 2026).
Panel preparation comes from the specifications that cite D1748. The 1993 text of MIL-PRF-16173E uses low carbon steel panels of 1/8 by 2 by 4 inches conforming to D1748, cleaned with solvents and abraded to a surface finish of 10-20 microinches root mean square (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993). Because the cleaning uses flammable solvents, the step follows each solvent's SDS, and the specification states that safety equipment and ventilation "shall be utilized when using solvents" (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993).
How is an ASTM D1748 pass or fail decided from rust dots?
After the exposure period, the laboratory counts and sizes the rust dots inside each panel's significant area, the part of the panel where rust counts. It then compares them with the limit named in the product specification. The method itself leaves interpretation open: ASTM states that D1748 "does not prescribe the exposure periods to be used for a specific product, nor the interpretation to be given to the results" (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.4). The specification supplies the rule, and the laboratory applies it.
MIL-PRF-16173E shows what a typical rule looks like. Its 1993 text exposes three coated panels and passes the compound if "none of the panels show more than a trace of corrosion on the leading test surface of the panel" (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993). A trace has a fixed meaning: "A trace of corrosion is defined as not greater than three dots of rust, no one of which is larger than 1 millimeter in diameter." (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993). And only rust in the right place counts: "Only corrosion within significant areas as outlined in ASTM D 1748 shall be considered." (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993).
Other standards rate rust differently. JIS K 2246:2026 has its own measuring method of degree of rust formation, separate from its humidity cabinet test (JIS K 2246:2026, clauses 6.4 and 6.34). A pass under one specification's rule therefore does not carry over to another.
For that reason, ask the laboratory to report, for each panel, the number of dots, the size of the largest dot and where each dot sits. With those details the result can be checked against whichever rule applies.
How do you read ASTM D1748 humidity cabinet results?
Check the result against the hours and dot rule fixed before the test. Then ask whether high humidity is the main cause of rust in the intended service. ASTM limits what any result can show: the data are "of interest only in eliminating the most unsuitable materials or for indicating a probable relative order of protection against rust under conditions of high humidity" (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.4).
The table below sets out what each ASTM D1748 result means and what to do next.
ASTM D1748 result | Meaning | Action |
|---|---|---|
Pass at the agreed hours, within the dot rule (for example no more than three dots, none over 1 mm: MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993) | Not among the most unsuitable materials for high humidity (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.4) | Accept for humid storage screening; do not convert hours into months |
A few small dots near the panel edge | May fall outside the significant area that counts (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993) | Check dot positions against the D1748 significant area; keep the rule fixed before the result |
Fail with many or large dots | Unsuitable for this humidity duty, or a panel preparation fault | Check the reference panel and panel preparation; repeat, then reject |
Different result in a second cabinet | Within the known spread; repeat tests in more than one cabinet "are sometimes desirable" (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.3) | Run repeats and decide on the pattern across runs |
Pass, but service rust comes from salt or condensation | Outside what D1748 predicts (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.1) | Add salt spray or condensation tests matched to the exposure |
The first row matters most. A pass at the agreed hours only shows that the preservative is not among the worst for high humidity. It does not say how many months parts will stay rust free in a warehouse or a container.
Treat the second and fourth rows as prompts to check the evidence, not as verdicts. Neither one changes the rule, and both call for more data on where and how often rust appears.
How many hours should an ASTM D1748 humidity cabinet test run?
Run the test for the hours named in the governing product specification. Without one, agree the hours in writing before the test, based on experience with that type of preservative in the intended service. The method itself sets no number. ASTM states: "The test life required for each type of metal preservative and for each intended application should be based on actual experience with that type of preservative in the intended service." (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.2).
Specifications fill the gap, each in its own way. The 1993 text of MIL-PRF-16173E requires, for grades 2, 3, 4 and 5, that coated panels "be exposed for a minimum of 30 days in a humidity cabinet" (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993). Check the edition before relying on that figure: EverySpec lists MIL-PRF-16173E with Interim Amendment 2 dated 2017-10-19 as used in lieu of the base document (EverySpec, accessed 2026). Confirm the current value against the amendment before quoting 30 days. JIS K 2246:2026 carries its own method for humidity cabinet test in clause 6.34 (JIS K 2246:2026), which applies to products sold to that standard.
Longer hours do not convert into months of storage. A practical way to set hours is to run a reference preservative, one whose field behavior is already known, beside the candidate, and choose an exposure long enough to separate the two.
ASTM also limits comparisons: they "should normally be limited to similar metal preservative combinations designed for similar applications" (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.2). Hours set for a thin oil film therefore do not suit a hard film compound.
How do you fix the ASTM D1748 pass criterion and control panel before the test?
Before any panel enters the cabinet, write down the exposure hours, the dot rule, the number of panels, the reference preservative and the inspection schedule. The timing matters. D1748 leaves both exposure periods and interpretation to the user (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.4), so a rule written after the result can be bent to fit it.
A workable ASTM D1748 test plan has five lines:
Exposure hours, from the specification or from service experience with that preservative type (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.2).
The dot rule, such as the MIL-PRF-16173E trace limit for grades 2, 3, 4 and 5 of no more than three dots, none over 1 mm (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993).
Panels per product; MIL-PRF-16173E uses three for those grades (MIL-PRF-16173E, 1993).
A reference preservative of known field performance, run in the same cabinet at the same time.
Repeat runs, since "a number of repeat tests may be necessary to establish the test life of a given metal preservative" (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.3).
The reference panel, the control coated with the reference preservative, turns a single result into a relative one. That is the only kind of result the method claims to give.
When a run partly passes, for example two of three panels within the rule, the plan decides the outcome, not the judgment of the moment. For the same decision in plant trials, see the guide on what to do when a chemical trial result only partly passes.
Why do ASTM D1748 results predict poorly where humidity is not the main cause of rust?
The cabinet reproduces one mechanism: steady high humidity at a raised temperature. It leaves out salt, acid vapors, liquid water and temperature cycling, so its results predict poorly wherever humidity is not the main cause of rust. ASTM states the limit directly: the method "should not be relied upon to predict the effectiveness of a metal preservative in which high humidity is not the principal factor in the rusting" (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.1). An equipment maker adds that the cabinet climate "is maintained under constant steady state conditions" (Ascott Analytical, accessed 2026).
Real storage and shipping often bring back what the cabinet leaves out. Parts near the coast or shipped by sea meet salt. Parts in unheated stores or containers can see dew form on cold steel as temperatures swing. This suggests that, for those exposures, a D1748 pass is weak evidence: the rust there starts from salt deposits or liquid water rather than from humid air alone.
Other accelerated tests carry the same warning about prediction. Of salt fog, ASTM writes: "Prediction of performance in natural environments has seldom been correlated with salt spray results when used as stand-alone data." (ASTM B117-26a, clause 3.2). For condensation tests of coatings, results "should not be represented as being equivalent to a period of exposure to water in the natural environment, until the degree of quantitative correlation has been established" (ASTM D4585/D4585M-25, clause 4.3). No single cabinet stands in for the field.
What are common mistakes when comparing ASTM D1748 results?
Most mistakes come from treating a relative, humidity-only screen as an absolute storage rating. Five recur when two preservatives or two suppliers are compared:
Comparing hours from different laboratories or cabinets without repeats. ASTM notes that "the precision of the test method appears to be less than desired" (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.3).
Comparing unlike products, such as a thin oil and a hard film compound, against the method's advice to keep comparisons to "similar metal preservative combinations designed for similar applications" (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.2).
Converting cabinet hours into months of storage, which the method does not support (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.4).
Changing the dot rule or the significant area after seeing the panels, when the method leaves interpretation to a rule the user must fix first (ASTM D1748-24, clause 4.4).
Quoting a specification value without its edition or amendment, such as the 1993 MIL-PRF-16173E humidity hours, when Interim Amendment 2 is used in lieu of the base text (EverySpec, accessed 2026).
Each of these makes two ASTM D1748 numbers look comparable when they are not. The fix is a written plan that applies the same hours, rule, panel count and reference preservative to every product in the comparison.
Which tests should you use alongside ASTM D1748?
Pair ASTM D1748 with tests that match the other causes of rust in the intended service: salt spray for salt exposure, controlled condensation for dew on cold steel, and in-package or vapor tests for packed parts. The table below matches each service question to a method.
Service question | Method | What it adds |
|---|---|---|
Salt exposure in coastal storage or sea freight | ASTM B117-26a salt spray; JIS K 2246:2026, clause 6.35 neutral salt spray | Relative corrosion resistance in a controlled salt fog (ASTM B117-26a, clause 3.1) |
Dew on cold steel | ASTM D4585/D4585M-25 controlled condensation | Condensation exposure; usable for corrosion tests if specimens are periodically dried (ASTM D4585/D4585M-25, clause 4.5) |
Parts stored in their packaging | JIS K 2246:2026, clause 6.37 storability-in-package | Protection inside the package (JIS K 2246:2026) |
Vapor-phase protection | JIS K 2246:2026, clause 6.39 vapour inhibitor ability | Protection away from the coated surface (JIS K 2246:2026) |
For exported parts, the first row matters most. If parts travel by sea, a salt spray result belongs beside the humidity cabinet result. Bear in mind that ASTM B117 also "does not prescribe the type of test specimen or exposure periods to be used for a specific product, nor the interpretation to be given to the results" (ASTM B117-26a, clause 1.2).
Lubinpla, an applied AI company for specialty chemicals, evaluates a test result from the customer's own reports against the criteria and method fixed before the result, never changing them afterward, and states the scope the result covers in one cited document for the user to review.
Key takeaways
ASTM D1748-24 ranks metal preservatives under steady high humidity; it gives no storage life.
The method sets no hours and leaves the interpretation of rust dots to the specification; fix both before the test.
MIL-PRF-16173E's 1993 text counts a trace as no more than three dots, none over 1 mm, inside the significant area.
Precision is limited, so a sound result includes repeat runs, a reference preservative and a second cabinet.
Where salt or condensation drives rust, add salt spray or condensation tests rather than longer cabinet hours.