Make-up water in a closed loop: when the volume is too high
Summary
A closed loop typically needs make-up water of less than 5% of its system volume per year (NIH, 2023). Any meter rise above the baseline recorded after filling is a possible leak; confirm it when conductivity, pH or alkalinity and inhibitor level fall together (Chem-Aqua, 2018). The 5% figure is a typical value, not a regulatory limit.
Closed-loop make-up requirements are typically less than 5% of the total system volume in a year (NIH, 2023).
Losing 25% of system volume per month is not uncommon in practice, typically from mechanical seal leaks or expansion tank overflow (NIH, 2023).
For losses above 1 gpm (about 3.8 L/min), Chem-Aqua suggests a 3/4 inch (20 mm) meter on a bypass of the make-up line to quantify the rate (Chem-Aqua, 2018).
BSRIA BG 50/2021, the second edition of its closed-system water treatment guide, is a guide, not a standard or regulation (BSRIA, 2022).
These readings apply to closed hot water, chilled water and closed condenser water loops in buildings, filled with water or a water-glycol mix and dosed with a chemical inhibitor. They do not apply to steam systems, open cooling towers, or loops that are drained or bled on purpose.
How much make-up water does a closed loop normally use?
Once a closed loop has been filled, vented and dosed, it should use almost no make-up water, the water added to replace losses: typically less than 5% of the total system volume in a year (NIH, 2023). Chem-Aqua describes closed heating and cooling systems as needing little make-up water and minimal chemical additions after the initial charge (Chem-Aqua, 2018). A Heating Help forum discussion on hot water heating goes further: any make-up at all means a leak, because the only way water can leave a closed system is a leak (Heating Help, 2025).
Real loops often lose more than either view allows. The US National Institutes of Health notes that losing 25% of system volume per month is not uncommon, typically through mechanical seals or expansion tank overflow (NIH, 2023).
The table below turns the 5% figure (NIH, 2023) into an illustrative monthly meter allowance for three loop sizes: the number to hold a site visit reading against.
System volume | 5% per year (NIH, 2023) | Average per month (illustrative) |
|---|---|---|
2,000 L | 100 L | About 8 L |
10,000 L | 500 L | About 42 L |
50,000 L | 2,500 L | About 208 L |
So for a 10,000 L loop, a meter that has moved more than about 42 L in a month is already running faster than the typical annual rate (illustrative).
How do you set a make-up water baseline after filling a closed loop?
Set the baseline once the loop is filled, vented, dosed and stable. It is a set of readings, not one number: the meter reading plus the water chemistry the loop should hold, because a later meter rise means little without the chemistry that confirms it. Record:
The make-up meter reading, with date and time, taken once venting is done and pressure has settled.
The system volume, from the design data or the fill record, so later make-up can be stated as a percentage per year.
Conductivity, pH or alkalinity and inhibitor level of the loop water, which Chem-Aqua uses to verify water loss (Chem-Aqua, 2018).
Conductivity of the fill water, which the dilution check below needs to work out how much loop water has been replaced.
Every chemical addition, with date and amount, so a later drop in inhibitor is not misread.
The cold-fill pressure, the state of the expansion vessel and the pressure regulator setting.
Chemistry goes into the baseline because once a loop is adequately protected, it should not need further chemical addition unless bacteria or the loss and replacement of system water deplete the chemical (BSRIA, 2022).
Take a fresh baseline after every repair, drain-down or refill, since each one resets both the meter and the chemistry.
How do you read the make-up water meter on a site visit?
On a site visit, convert the meter change since the last reading into litres per month and into a percentage of system volume per year, then check it against the water chemistry. A meter reading alone can mislead in both directions, because some meters do not register water losses until they are significant (Chem-Aqua, undated). The table pairs each meter result with what the chemistry shows and what to do next.
Reading | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
Meter flat since last visit | No measurable make-up | Confirm the meter turns; keep the interval |
Meter rise, inhibitor and conductivity falling together | Water loss confirmed (Chem-Aqua, 2018) | Find the leak; redose to target |
Meter rise, chemistry unchanged | Top-up after air venting, chemical added since the last test, or a meter fault | Check vent and fill records, the chemical log and the meter |
Chemistry falling, meter flat | Unmetered fill path, or chemical consumed | Check bypass fills and bacteria |
Rise after a repair or drain-down | Planned refill, not a leak | Record it and reset the baseline |
The second row is the one that decides a leak: a meter rise with inhibitor and conductivity falling together confirms water loss.
Log each reading with who took it, when, and which baseline it was compared against, in a technical service report the customer acts on. Lubinpla's site inspection follows the same order: it sets the check scope and deviation criteria from the baseline first, then compares meter and water quality readings against them.
How do conductivity and inhibitor levels confirm closed loop water loss?
Conductivity and inhibitor levels confirm water loss when they fall together, because fresh make-up water dilutes everything in the loop at the same rate. Chem-Aqua uses routine tests of conductivity, pH or alkalinity and inhibitor level to determine whether water has been lost: if these parameters decrease simultaneously, it has (Chem-Aqua, 2018). The size of the drop also estimates how much water was lost.
Take an illustrative case. A 10,000 L loop had a baseline nitrite level of 800 mg/L and now reads 600 mg/L; no chemical was added in between, and the make-up water contains no nitrite. For a single loss and refill, the replaced fraction is (800 minus 600) divided by 800, or 25%, about 2,500 L. Conductivity gives a cross-check that allows for the conductivity the fill water brings in: with a baseline of 2,000 µS/cm, fill water at 400 µS/cm and a reading of 1,600 µS/cm, the fraction is (2,000 minus 1,600) divided by (2,000 minus 400), again 25% (illustrative). If water is lost and replaced gradually rather than all at once, the same drop corresponds to a somewhat larger volume, about 2,900 L in this example (illustrative).
Then compare the result with the meter. If the meter shows far less than the chemistry implies, look for an unmetered fill path (a route where water enters without passing the meter) or a meter fault. If inhibitor falls while conductivity holds, suspect consumption rather than loss: nitrite is a nutrient for denitrifying bacteria (NIH, 2023).
What besides a leak raises closed loop make-up water?
Besides a pipework leak, make-up rises when a component releases water by design or by fault, or when water escapes into another system. Chem-Aqua's checklist covers each case (Chem-Aqua, 2018):
Leaking pump seals or packing.
An expansion tank that has filled with water, so the relief valve lifts as the water heats up. Chem-Aqua says to drain it to about a third full when the system is cold.
A failed pressure regulator on the make-up line, which lets pressure rise until the relief valve opens. Chem-Aqua sets the regulator at 2 psig (about 14 kPa) above the highest head in the system (Chem-Aqua, 2018).
Automatic air vents that leak water, especially vents piped to a drain.
A missing or failed backflow preventer, which can let system water flow back into the make-up line.
A leaking fan coil, found by testing the condensate drain pan water for treatment chemical or hardness.
A leaking heat exchanger between a steam system and a hot water loop, which shows up as contamination in the condensate or boiler water.
The Chem-Aqua and NCH leak guide adds filters backwashed with system water (Chem-Aqua, undated). Meter faults belong on the list too. They raise the reading with no water lost, which is why the chemistry check matters.
Where closed loop make-up water limits do not apply
Closed loop make-up water limits do not apply where water leaves the system on purpose or bypasses the meter. Steam systems are a different case: their air vents release some water vapor on every boiler cycle, so a hot water rule of zero make-up does not fit them (Heating Help, 2025).
A glycol loop topped up from its own mix tank adds fluid that the city water meter never sees. For these systems, the US Department of Veterans Affairs specification provides a separate glycol-water make-up tank and pump (US Department of Veterans Affairs, 2010), so track that tank level as a second meter. A loop drained for repairs, or one feeding a side-stream filter that is backwashed with system water, has planned losses: log them and leave them out of the comparison.
The 5% per year figure (NIH, 2023) is not a design limit either. BSRIA BG 50/2021 is a guide, not a standard or regulation (BSRIA, 2022), and the German standard VDI 2035 Part 1 places its emphasis on fill water quality and reducing oxygen entry into the system (BSRIA, 2022). Where a contract or maker sets a lower figure, that figure governs.
Frequently asked questions
Should a closed loop make-up line have a water meter?
Yes. A make-up meter is the simplest way to see water loss, as long as you read it with the chemistry. Some meters do not register small losses (Chem-Aqua, undated), and Chem-Aqua suggests a 3/4 inch bypass meter once losses exceed 1 gpm (Chem-Aqua, 2018).
Why does a closed loop lose water through the relief valve?
Water leaves through the relief valve when the expansion tank has no air space left, or when a failed make-up pressure regulator lets system pressure climb. To check the regulator, Chem-Aqua fits gauges before and after it and reads them with the temperature stable (Chem-Aqua, 2018).
How often should closed loop make-up readings be taken?
Take a make-up meter reading and a conductivity and inhibitor test at every scheduled water treatment visit, and after any repair or drain-down. Regular monitoring tracks changes over time and shows whether treatment stays effective (NIH, 2023).