Lubinpla

Magnesium machining coolant: choosing for hydrogen and pH drift

Summary

Choose a magnesium-rated water-miscible coolant with pH buffering when heat and productivity matter, and neat oil when fines and hydrogen control come first. Neither choice holds without fire controls in place: flushing that stops chip build-up, extraction, and vented chip containers, because wet magnesium chips release hydrogen and tend to self-ignite (DGUV, 2020).

  • DGUV Information 209-090 states that water-miscible metalworking fluids, frequently at about pH 9, react easily with magnesium and form hydrogen (DGUV, 2020).

  • DGUV treats magnesium particles above 500 µm mean diameter as chips, and particles below 500 µm as dust that is explosive when whirled up (DGUV, 2020).

  • One magnesium-specific water-miscible fluid is buffered to hold pH around 8.8 to 9.2, while general machining fluids often start at pH 9 or above (CTE Magazine, 2015).

  • In immersion tests, a magnesium hydroxide film on the metal stabilizes at pH 10.0 to 10.5, and high alkalinization accompanies magnesium corrosion in water (Lamaka et al., 2017).

This guide covers turning, milling, drilling and grinding of magnesium alloys with more than 80 wt% magnesium, the range DGUV Information 209-090 addresses (DGUV, 2020). It does not cover die casting, melting or blasting, and it does not replace the machine maker's fire protection concept or the fire code that applies at your site.

Which conditions decide the coolant for machining magnesium?

Five conditions decide the coolant for machining magnesium: the chip form the operation produces, the heat and tool wear the cut generates, how chips and sludge leave the machine, whether the machine has extraction and fire protection for the chosen fluid, and whether anyone will check the fluid every week.

Chip form comes first. DGUV Information 209-090 calls magnesium particles above 500 µm mean diameter chips and treats particles below 500 µm as dust that is explosive when whirled up (DGUV, 2020). Turning and drilling mostly make chips; grinding, brushing and polishing make dust and, with a water-miscible fluid, sludge.

Heat and productivity favor water. Magnesium Products Limited converted die-casting machining from dry cutting to oil-in-water emulsions and reported fire protection, tool life, housekeeping and productivity gains, after it addressed emulsion splitting, hydrogen generation and salt deposits (Spicer et al., 1991).

Chip handling and the machine decide whether a fluid is safe to run. A water-miscible fluid needs flushing, extraction and vents so hydrogen cannot collect, while a neat oil needs oil mist extraction, and integrated fire detection and suppression where the operation carries a high fire risk (DGUV, 2020).

Monitoring closes the list. DGUV points to regular checks of water-miscible fluids, for example weekly, for pH, concentration and nitrite (DGUV, 2020). If a shop cannot keep that routine on a magnesium machine, it should give neat oil more weight.

Why does water-based coolant make hydrogen and drift in pH with magnesium?

Water-based coolant makes hydrogen with magnesium because magnesium corrodes in water. The reaction forms magnesium hydroxide and releases hydrogen gas, and that hydroxide pushes the coolant pH upward. DGUV Information 209-090 states that water-miscible metalworking fluids react easily with magnesium because of their alkaline properties, frequently around pH 9, and form hydrogen (DGUV, 2020).

The pH drift follows from the same corrosion reaction. Corrosion researchers note that high alkalinization accompanies magnesium corrosion, and that a magnesium hydroxide film on the metal stabilizes at pH 10.0 to 10.5 (Lamaka et al., 2017). A review of cutting fluid corrosion inhibitors puts the working pH of almost all cutting fluids at 8.0 to 11.0 (Li et al., 2022). So a general fluid that starts near pH 9 has little room before dissolved magnesium carries it toward the range where hydroxide deposits form. That conclusion is an inference from the two sources, not a measured limit.

Blaser Swisslube described the field effects in a trade interview: magnesium raises fluid pH, which can cause foaming, staining of the material and hard magnesium deposits on tools and machines (CTE Magazine, 2015). The same supplier said its magnesium fluid uses a pH buffer to hold about 8.8 to 9.2, starting low and rising during machining (CTE Magazine, 2015).

Hydrogen does not stop when the spindle stops. DGUV asks for vents at the top of the machine enclosure and the extraction system, extraction overrun after machining, and inhibitor additives that largely minimize hydrogen formation (DGUV, 2020).

Which coolant types fit magnesium machining where?

Which magnesium machining coolant type fits depends on the operation and on chip handling. Buffered water-miscible fluids suit coarse-chip production with strong flushing. Neat oils suit fine chips and grinding, where hydrogen and wet sludge are the larger risk. Dry cutting or minimum quantity lubrication, which leaves chips dry or only slightly oily, suits single parts with immediate chip removal.

The table below matches each set of magnesium machining conditions to a coolant type. The fire and handling controls apply to every option first.

Your conditions

Coolant type for magnesium

Why

What to watch

Production turning or drilling, coarse chips, chip conveyor, vented containers

Magnesium-rated water-miscible emulsion with pH buffer and inhibitor

Cooling and flush cleaning keep the chip fire load low (DGUV, 2020)

pH, concentration and nitrite weekly (DGUV, 2020); water hardness; hydrogen vents

High-speed milling, high heat, enclosed center with extraction and fire suppression

Water-miscible as above, or neat oil with the highest flash point available

Both work if the enclosure is built for that fluid

Neat oil: mist flashover and oil fire spreading to chips (DGUV, 2020)

Grinding or polishing, fines and sludge

Neat oil, or water-miscible only with filtration and vented sludge handling

Sludge from water-miscible grinding tends to self-ignite (DGUV, 2020)

Regular filter fleece and sludge removal (DGUV, 2020)

Single parts, short runs, no magnesium fluid circuit

Dry cutting, or minimum quantity lubrication with flash point at least 150 °C (DGUV, 2020)

No hydrogen, no wet chips

Dry chips ignite from friction heat; remove chips, no compressed air

The grinding row matters most. Once an operation makes fines, the wet sludge a water-miscible fluid creates becomes the main hazard, so this guide puts neat oil first unless filtration and vented sludge containers are already in place. DGUV Information 209-090 itself does not rank the two fluids for grinding.

Shops most often get the milling row wrong. A neat oil does not by itself make an enclosed machining center safer: DGUV asks for an extraction system that must run before the machine starts, and for fire detection and suppression fast enough to stop an oil fire before it reaches the magnesium chips (DGUV, 2020). Without those controls, the buffered water-miscible fluid is the safer of the two.

How do magnesium fines and wet chips change the fire risk?

Magnesium fines and wet chips shift the fire risk from a hot-chip fire to self-heating, hydrogen release and dust explosion. DGUV Information 209-090 states that chips wetted with water-miscible metalworking fluids tend to self-ignite, which may result in a fire or, in the worst case, an explosion (DGUV, 2020).

Fines raise the risk through their surface area. DGUV notes that sludge from machining with water-miscible fluids tends to self-ignite because of its low particle size, and that violent reactions, fires and oxyhydrogen explosions mainly occur when large sludge quantities are stored in barrels and tippers (DGUV, 2020).

The filter fleece that catches these particles needs the same care. Filter fleece covered with moist magnesium particles is a reactive fire load and has to be removed regularly into non-combustible, closed containers with vents (DGUV, 2020).

Neat oil removes the hydrogen path but adds an oil fire path. DGUV warns that high temperature at the cut, especially with too little fluid, can cause an oil fire, and that an oil fire can ignite the magnesium chips (DGUV, 2020).

Before setting up chip storage, read the coolant SDS sections on reactivity and disposal. Then follow DGUV Information 209-090 clause 6 or, in the US, NFPA 660, which has absorbed NFPA 484 Standard for Combustible Metals, together with the rules of your local fire authority. DGUV recommends vented closed containers for chips wetted with water-mixed fluid, briquettes with residual moisture not above 3%, and fire class D extinguishing agents on hand. It also says water must never be used on a magnesium fire in dry grinding (DGUV, 2020).

Why do magnesium ions split coolant emulsions?

Magnesium ions split coolant emulsions through electrical charge. Dissolved magnesium is a positively charged ion, and it neutralizes the anionic, meaning negatively charged, emulsifiers that most oil-based water-miscible fluids use. The oil droplets lose their charge and separate. Blaser Swisslube explained in a trade interview that dissolved magnesium builds up in the fluid and splits or separates most metalworking fluids, and that an anionic emulsifier is separated by the positive charge of the dissolved magnesium (CTE Magazine, 2015).

Magnesium build-up also hardens the fluid. DGUV Information 209-090 describes solid magnesium soaps and a rise in water hardness, called salting, which can form glass-hard crusts that clog pumps and circuits and cut the fluid supply to the cut (DGUV, 2020). DGUV recommends controlling water hardness regularly and filtering magnesium particles out of the emulsion, for example with a filter fleece or pressure belt filter, to delay salting (DGUV, 2020).

Changing the emulsifier is not a free fix. The same supplier said other emulsifier types can be too hard and cause foaming or staining, and that a stable end-use dilution needs a special emulsifier system (CTE Magazine, 2015).

Corrosion inhibitors also behave differently on magnesium: a review notes that sebacic acid triethanolamine salt protects magnesium alloys poorly in cutting fluids, while a silicate and surfactant combination reached 95.3% inhibition efficiency in one laboratory study (Li et al., 2022).

What should you ask a supplier about a magnesium machining coolant?

Ask a supplier of a magnesium machining coolant for in-use evidence on emulsion stability, pH, hydrogen and deposits on your alloy, not for fresh-dilution data. A supplier statement such as low hydrogen generation stays a claim until a trial on your machine confirms it.

Questions for a water-miscible magnesium coolant:

  • Which magnesium alloys and operations has the fluid been run on, and for how long?

  • Which emulsifier type does it use, and how much dissolved magnesium does it tolerate before splitting?

  • What pH does it start at and hold in use, and which buffer holds it?

  • What hydrogen generation data exists, and under which test conditions?

  • Which make-up water hardness does it need, and how should salting be monitored?

For a neat oil, ask about the flash point, the evaporation loss and the viscosity at 40 °C, because DGUV recommends the oil with the lowest evaporation loss and the highest flash point for the viscosity the process needs (DGUV, 2020).

For both, ask for the SDS and the fluid maker's monitoring plan, since DGUV recommends inspecting and maintaining the fluid in close cooperation with the fluid maker (DGUV, 2020). Apply the same discipline to any shortlist: see what a chemical product recommendation should include before you compare offers.

Lubinpla's product recommendation first reads the project's material, machining conditions and condition measurement history, applies fire and handling conditions to every candidate, and leaves anything it cannot confirm as an item to confirm by test.

Frequently asked questions

Can you put out a magnesium chip fire with water?

No. DGUV Information 209-090 says water must under no circumstances be used to extinguish a fire in dry magnesium grinding and asks for fire class D extinguishing agents for metal fires (DGUV, 2020). At the temperatures of burning magnesium, water splits into hydrogen and oxygen, which react explosively (DGUV, 2020). Inform the local fire brigade before magnesium work starts.

Is minimum quantity lubrication an option for magnesium?

Yes, with limits. DGUV recommends minimum quantity lubrication lubricants with a flash point of at least 150 °C and a high viscosity to reduce the risk of fire (DGUV, 2020). Dry and slightly oil-containing magnesium chips from this process still go into tightly sealed, non-combustible containers such as steel barrels (DGUV, 2020).

Does machining magnesium dry avoid the coolant problems?

Dry machining avoids hydrogen and emulsion problems but not fire. DGUV states that dry chips may ignite at high temperatures or from friction heat, and that grinding dust adds a dust explosion hazard (DGUV, 2020). Remove chips often, and never blow them out with compressed air.

How often should a magnesium machining coolant be checked?

DGUV points to regular monitoring of water-miscible fluids, for example weekly, for pH, concentration and nitrite under DGUV Rule 109-003 (DGUV, 2020). On magnesium, add water hardness to the checks, because salting builds up as magnesium dissolves, and remove loaded filter fleece and empty chip containers at intervals set in the cleaning schedule (DGUV, 2020).

Related posts