Lubinpla

HEES Biodegradable Hydraulic Oil and NBR Seal Compatibility

Summary

Only if the NBR compound passes an ISO 6072 test for compatibility in that HEES fluid at the system's maximum operating temperature and contact time. Makers of saturated-ester HEES disagree: some rate NBR compatible, others recommend FKM for dynamic seals, and published NBR data shows swelling at 100 °C (BIONA, 2026). A generic chart cannot settle it.

  • ISO 15380:2023, Edition 4, defines HEES as the synthetic ester category among four environmentally acceptable hydraulic fluid categories (ISO, 2026).

  • ISO 6072:2011 provides five standard reference elastomers for fluid tests, including NBR 1, NBR 2 and FKM 2, and was last confirmed in 2026 (ISO, 2026).

  • In one saturated-ester ISO VG 46 HEES, the ISO 6072 test at 100 °C for 168 h gave NBR 1 a volume change of 14.9% and a hardness change of -10 Shore A, against 1.2% and -2 for FKM 2 (BIONA data sheet, 2026).

  • One saturated-ester HEES maker recommends FKM for seals under dynamic stress (FUCHS PI 4-1273, 2021).

When is HEES compatible with NBR seals, and when not?

HEES biodegradable hydraulic oil suits NBR seals only when two things hold. The fluid maker's elastomer data must cover your NBR grade at your top temperature, and the maker must not have excluded the seal's duty, such as a moving rod seal. A data sheet rating describes one ester formula tested against a reference compound: the standard test elastomer, not your seal. It does not cover every HEES or every NBR seal in your machine.

Judge each seal by the worst condition it sees. A fluid that suits a static cover seal at moderate temperature can still fail a moving rod seal running at its peak temperature. Ask the fluid maker which ester type, test temperature and immersion time its rating covers.

The table sets out a verdict for each condition and the check that confirms it.

Condition

Verdict

Why

Saturated-ester HEES whose data sheet rates NBR compatible, static seal, temperature inside the maker's test

Conditionally compatible

One maker rates NBR, HNBR, AU and FPM seals as good for its saturated-ester HEES (TotalEnergies Biohydran SE, 2026); confirm with that fluid's ISO 6072 data

Same fluid, dynamic rod or piston seal

Conditionally compatible; FKM preferred by one maker

FKM recommended for seals under dynamic stress (FUCHS PI 4-1273, 2021)

Peak temperature above the maker's test temperature, or contact longer than its test

Not confirmed

NBR 1 swelled 14.9% at 100 °C after 168 h in one HEES (BIONA data sheet, 2026) and 11.2% at 80 °C after 1,000 h in another (FUCHS PI 4-1273, 2021); NBR service limit 120 °C in general (Power & Motion, 2026)

Unsaturated ester, ester type not stated, or no elastomer data

Not confirmed

No data covers the pair; test before use

System converted from mineral oil with existing NBR seals

Conditionally compatible

Follow the ISO 15380 changeover procedure and check filters after 50 operating hours (FUCHS PI 4-1273, 2021)

Read the dynamic seal row first. A saturated-ester HEES can carry an NBR rating while its own maker still recommends FKM where seals move (FUCHS PI 4-1273, 2021).

Why do HEES makers disagree about NBR seals?

Each HEES maker rates its own ester formula under its own test conditions, and NBR compounds differ from one seal supplier to the next, so the ratings differ. TotalEnergies states that Biohydran SE, a saturated-ester HEES, "has a good compatibility level with NBR, HNBR, AU and FPM seals" (TotalEnergies Biohydran SE, 2026). FUCHS says its saturated-ester PLANTOSYN HVI fluids are compatible with materials usually found in hydraulic systems, but for dynamic stress "the use of viton FKM material is recommended" (FUCHS PI 4-1273, 2021).

A seal maker's guide takes a harder line, rating NBR as having "poor resistance to polyol-ester biodegradable fluids (HEES)" (Power & Motion, 2026). The same guide explains why the ratings split: compatibility "is never a simple yes-or-no decision", because ratings vary by compound formulation, additive package, operating temperature and exposure duration (Power & Motion, 2026). The US EPA summary of environmentally acceptable lubricants likewise notes that synthetic esters are incompatible with some seal materials (US EPA, 2011).

All three statements can be true at once, because they rate different fluids, compounds and duties. For seals that fail even when the chart says compatible, see the post on why seals fail when the compatibility chart says compatible.

What happens to NBR seals if the HEES does not suit them?

In a HEES fluid that does not suit them, NBR seals usually swell, soften and lose strength. The damage shows first as leaks at dynamic seals. Published ISO 6072 data for one saturated-ester HEES shows how large the effect can be: at 100 °C for 168 h, NBR 1 changed volume by 14.9%, hardness by -10 Shore A and tensile strength by -15%, while FKM 2 changed volume by 1.2% (BIONA data sheet, 2026).

Swelling changes how the seal fits. Apple Rubber's seal design guide describes excessive swell as "a marked increase in seal dimensions" that "results in a reduction of physical properties and can result in improper sizing between seal and gland", and notes that dynamic applications are especially prone because friction accelerates seal failure (Apple Rubber, 2026).

Look for these signs after a switch to HEES:

  • Weeping or leaks at rod seals and pump shaft seals.

  • Seals that feel soft, sticky or oversized when removed.

  • Extrusion marks or nibbling at the seal edges.

  • Faster loss of fluid between top-ups than before conversion.

If any of these appear after conversion, suspect the seal compound, the fluid temperature, or both. Run the test below before you fit a new seal of the same compound.

How do you test NBR compatibility with a HEES fluid?

ISO 6072:2011 sets the method. You immerse test pieces in that exact fluid under controlled conditions and measure hardness, volume, tensile strength and elongation before and after. The standard covers "mineral-based, fire-resistant and biodegradable hydraulic fluids" and states that service elastomers "may be tested using these compatibility procedures if required" (ISO, 2026).

A practical test request covers five points:

  1. Name the fluid by product and batch, and its ISO 15380 category (HEES).

  2. Supply your actual seal compound from the seal maker, plus NBR 1 as the reference elastomer.

  3. Set the temperature at your system's measured peak, not the tank average.

  4. Set the immersion time to cover your duty; makers publish 168 h and 1,000 h results (BIONA data sheet, 2026; FUCHS PI 4-1273, 2021).

  5. Agree pass limits for each property with the seal maker before the result arrives.

Lubinpla's compatibility assessment takes the ester and the seal grade, adds temperature and contact time, and rates each pair as compatible, conditionally compatible or incompatible.

Frequently asked questions

Which seals to use instead of NBR in HEES systems?

Most HEES data favors FKM. In one saturated-ester HEES, FKM 2 changed volume by 1.2% at 100 °C after 168 h, against 14.9% for NBR 1 (BIONA data sheet, 2026). Standard FKM stiffens below -15 °C, so cold mobile equipment may need a low-temperature grade (Power & Motion, 2026).

Does leftover mineral oil after conversion affect NBR seals in HEES?

Biohydran SE, a saturated-ester HEES, is miscible with HM and HV mineral hydraulic fluids (TotalEnergies Biohydran SE, 2026). Other fluids can differ, so check miscibility on your fluid's data sheet. The larger risk is deposits: esters loosen mineral oil deposits that can clog filters after changeover (US EPA, 2011). Follow the fluid maker's changeover procedure and ask the maker for the residue limit.

Does an ISO 15380 HEES rating prove NBR compatibility?

No. ISO 15380:2023 recommends elastomer tests on reference compounds such as NBR 1, HNBR 1, FKM 2 and AU, which may differ from the seal compound in your machine (Texaco, 2026). Ask for the ISO 6072 results and the test temperature, not the category alone.

Related posts