Joint Account Reviews: What Each Side Should Get to See
Summary
Put agreed service results and open actions in the customer version, failure and test records in the manufacturer version, and keep sales judgments internal. The split applies when a distributor and a manufacturer review one shared industrial customer together. If the manufacturer also sells direct to that customer, competition rules narrow what the distributor can pass upstream.
Commission Regulation (EU) 2022/720, the EU vertical block exemption, entered into force on 1 June 2022 (European Commission, 2022).
Under Article 2(5) of Regulation (EU) 2022/720, the dual distribution exemption does not cover supplier and buyer information exchanges that are not directly related to implementing the agreement or not necessary to improve production or distribution (European Commission, 2023).
The EU Vertical Guidelines list individual information on identified end users as unlikely to be covered unless it is needed to meet that end user's requirements, for example after-sales service (Hogan Lovells, 2022).
ISO 10002:2018, edition 3, gives guidelines for complaints handling and was confirmed at stage 90.93 (ISO, 2018).
This answer covers a joint account review in which a distributor and the manufacturer of the products it resells review one industrial customer's technical service. It does not cover reviews inside one company, audits of a distributor's books, or legal advice. The EU rules below are one example; other jurisdictions apply their own competition and privacy law.
Which conditions decide what each side sees in a joint account review?
Three conditions decide what each side sees: who the reader is, whether the manufacturer also sells direct to the same customer, and whether the information names an identified person or site. Start with the reader. A customer contact needs results and commitments. A manufacturer's technical team needs evidence about its product. The distributor's own team needs everything, including judgments that would read badly outside.
The second condition is competitive overlap. A manufacturer that also sells direct competes with its own distributor at the resale level. That setup is called dual distribution, and in the EU the block exemption for that dual distribution covers only information exchanges that are directly related to the supply agreement and necessary to improve production or distribution (European Commission, 2023). Any pricing or customer detail that crosses over then needs a reason.
The third condition is identity. Names, phone numbers and email addresses of site contacts are personal data. The EU General Data Protection Regulation requires personal data to be "adequate, relevant and limited to what is necessary in relation to the purposes for which they are processed" (GDPR, Article 5(1)(c)). Settle all three conditions before anyone drafts a slide, because every later choice follows from them.
What belongs in the customer version of a joint account review and what stays internal?
The customer version holds the agreed service results, the open actions with an owner and a date, and the decisions the customer has to make. Anything that shows how the suppliers feel about the account stays internal.
Results are outcomes the customer can check against its own records: complaints closed, sample results returned, trials completed, product changes made. Give each one its date and the document it rests on. Open actions are what is still owed, by whom and by when. They include the customer's own actions, such as sending a fresh oil sample or confirming a process temperature.
Internal material stays out: opportunity notes, share-of-wallet estimates, account risk ratings, margin, the case history of who escalated what, and any confidence note such as "probably operator error". A customer who finds "probably operator error" in a review pack will dispute the whole document.
The customer version is also where you show service value in terms the buyer recognizes. The guide to preparing a quarterly business review for an industrial customer covers that step by step. Keep the pack short enough to read in the meeting.
Which technical records should a distributor hand to the manufacturer before a joint account review?
Hand the manufacturer the records its technical team needs to judge product performance: complaint and failure reports, sample and test results with method and lot, application conditions, and what was already tried. Send them before the meeting, so the manufacturer arrives with an answer instead of questions.
Each record should carry the product name and lot, the date, the test method or observation, the result, and the conditions of use (temperature, load, contamination, dosage or mixing ratio, as relevant). If the question is whether the lot met specification, attach the certificate of analysis. Record what was tried and what happened, failed fixes included. A manufacturer that repeats a failed fix loses time and credibility with the customer.
ISO 10002:2018 gives guidelines for "analysing and evaluating complaints in order to improve the quality of products and services" (ISO, 2018), and a manufacturer can only do that analysis with complete records.
Remove or replace customer identity unless the manufacturer needs it to serve that customer, for example to send an engineer to site. Technical content is treated differently: in the EU, the Vertical Guidelines list technical information on registration, certification, handling or use of the contract goods among the exchanges that should generally benefit from the block exemption (Hogan Lovells, 2022).
Joint account review visibility by audience
The table below places each item in one version of the review: the customer pack, the manufacturer pack, or the distributor's internal notes only.
Item | Customer | Manufacturer | Distributor only |
|---|---|---|---|
Agreed service results and KPIs | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Open actions with owner and date | Yes | Yes, its own actions | Yes |
Failure, sample and test records | Summary and outcome | Full records with lot and method | Yes |
Customer identity and site contacts | Not applicable | Only when needed for that customer's service (Vertical Guidelines, para. 100) | Yes |
Distributor future pricing and margin | No | No future resale prices (Vertical Guidelines, para. 100) | Yes |
Opportunity and account-risk notes | No | No | Yes |
Internal case history and confidence notes | No | Facts only, no blame | Yes |
The row that matters most is customer identity. The manufacturer sees named contacts only when it needs them to serve that customer; otherwise it gets the technical record without names. Two more rows settle most disputes. Failure and test records go to the manufacturer in full but reach the customer only as a summary and an outcome, because raw lot data invites argument about results that are still under investigation. Opportunity and account-risk notes stay with the distributor in every version.
When an item fits no row, ask which reader needs it to act, and leave it out of every other version. Keep the table with the review file, so the next person who prepares the review applies the same split without rebuilding it.
What customer and pricing information should a distributor not share with a manufacturer that also sells direct?
Do not share future resale prices or individual information on identified end users with a manufacturer that also sells direct to the same customers. The exception is identity the manufacturer needs to serve that customer. That is the EU position under Regulation (EU) 2022/720 and its Vertical Guidelines, which apply where the parties' market shares fall within the regulation's thresholds.
The Vertical Guidelines keep a list of exchanges unlikely to be covered by the exemption. It includes information on "the future prices at which the supplier or buyer intend to sell the contract goods or services downstream" (Hogan Lovells, 2022). The same list covers individual information on identified end users, except where it is necessary to adapt the goods, provide special conditions or after-sales service, or monitor a selective or exclusive distribution agreement (Hogan Lovells, 2022).
Other exchanges are allowed. These include aggregate customer purchases, preferences and feedback that do not identify end users, the prices at which the supplier sold to the buyer, and technical and logistical information (Hogan Lovells, 2022). Both lists rest on one principle: the exchange must be directly related to the agreement and necessary to improve production or distribution (European Commission, 2023). Outside the EU, check the local competition rules with counsel before the review, not after.
Who owns each follow-up action after a joint account review?
Each follow-up action needs one named owner from one organization and a due date, agreed in the meeting and written into the customer version. An action owned jointly by "distributor and manufacturer" tends to be owned by neither.
Give each action to whoever controls the outcome. The manufacturer owns product investigations, formulation or specification questions, and test work in its laboratory. The distributor owns customer contact, sampling logistics, on-site checks and passing results back. The customer owns actions on its own plant, such as changing a dosing setting or releasing a machine for inspection. If one action needs two parties, split it into two actions with two owners and a hand-off date between them.
Keep the actions in one list that all three parties see in their own version, with the same numbering, so that "action 4" means the same thing to everyone. Close an action only when its owner reports the result and the person who raised it accepts it. Carry open actions into the next review as the first agenda item, with the original due date still visible, so a slipped date stays a fact rather than a memory.
Common mistakes when preparing a joint account review
The most common mistake is building one slide pack and showing it to everyone. A single pack forces a bad choice: leak internal notes to the customer, or strip out the records the manufacturer needs. Build the distributor's full version first. Then derive the manufacturer and customer versions by removing items, never by rewriting results.
Other mistakes recur. Complaint reports go to the manufacturer without lot numbers or test methods, so the first meeting turns into a request for data. Customer contact lists get pasted into the manufacturer pack out of habit, which raises both competition and privacy questions when the manufacturer sells direct. Confidence notes such as "customer misused the product" survive into an external version. Pricing comes up in the joint meeting. In compliance reviews, distributors are often more willing to disclose sensitive commercial and financial information to an independent third party than directly to the manufacturer (Ankura, 2026), and a joint review is no place to test that.
Lubinpla, an applied AI company for specialty chemicals technical work, sets the reader of an account report (internal team, customer contact or manufacturer technical team) before drafting and leaves internal working notes, confidence scores and internal record sources out of documents for outside readers, with a person checking customer identity removal before approval. Whatever the tool, have a second person compare each external version against the visibility table before it goes out.
Frequently asked questions
Should the customer see the manufacturer's raw test data in a joint account review?
Usually not in raw form. Give the customer a summary of what was tested, the method, the result and what it means for their plant. Share the full raw data when the customer asks for it, when a specification or contract requires it, or once the investigation is closed and the data is final.
Can a distributor share its resale price with the manufacturer in a joint account review?
In the EU, where the manufacturer also sells direct, the prices at which the buyer resells the goods are on the Vertical Guidelines' list of exchanges that should generally be covered, provided the buyer stays free to set its own resale price, while future resale prices are on the list unlikely to be covered (Hogan Lovells, 2022). Keep future pricing out of joint reviews.
How often should a joint account review happen?
No standard sets a frequency. Most teams tie it to the customer's own review cycle or to contract milestones, and add an extra review after a serious complaint. Choose an interval that lets every open action reach a result before the next meeting.