Polyurea and lithium complex grease: mixing compatibility
Summary
Only if the two products pass ASTM D6185-24 testing at every mix ratio can you mix polyurea and lithium complex grease; otherwise purge the old grease first. SKF and US Bureau of Reclamation thickener charts rate the pair incompatible, yet some polyurea greases have passed D6185 with named lithium complex greases. The verdict covers grease-lubricated rolling bearings.
ASTM D6185-24 tests binary grease mixtures at 10:90, 50:50 and 90:10 and calls the pair incompatible if any mixture fails any of 3 primary tests (ASTM, 2024).
The NLGI grease guide reprinted by the US Bureau of Reclamation lists a 260+ °C dropping point for lithium complex and 243 °C for polyurea, with 177 °C maximum usable temperature for both (USBR FIST 2-4, 2024).
In an STLE reader survey of some 13,000 readers, 29% said they complete or request compatibility testing before using or recommending a grease (STLE TLT, 2013).
ExxonMobil states that its Polyrex EM polyurea greases have been shown compatible with a number of its lithium complex greases by the ASTM D6185 method (ExxonMobil, product data sheet).
When is mixing polyurea and lithium complex grease safe, and when not?
Mixing polyurea and lithium complex grease is safe only when the grease maker has D6185 data for the exact two products. The mix is unsafe whenever that data is missing, the bearing runs hot or fast, or the grease feeds a centralized system. ASTM D6185-24 blends the two greases at 10:90, 50:50 and 90:10 and checks dropping point, 100,000-stroke worked penetration and storage stability at elevated temperature (ASTM D6185-24, 1.2). The worked penetration test measures shear stability. If any one mixture fails any one of the three primary tests, the pair is incompatible (ASTM D6185-24, 1.3).
The table below decides whether a planned or accidental mix can stay in service.
Condition | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
No D6185 data for the two products, any ratio, any temperature | No, purge first | Charts rate polyurea with lithium complex incompatible (SKF, 2018; USBR FIST 2-4, 2024) |
Maker data shows a D6185 pass at 10:90, 50:50 and 90:10, bearing within both greases' rated temperature | Yes | All three mixtures passed all three primary tests (ASTM D6185-24, 1.3) |
Small top-up, about 10:90 new to old (illustrative), maker data shows a 50:50 pass but no 10:90 result, lightly loaded bearing at ambient temperature | Only as a stopgap, purge at the next stop | Dilute ratios can fail even when 50:50 passes (ASTM D6185-24, 5.3.1) |
High temperature or high speed bearing, near the 177 °C usable limit of both greases (NLGI guide via USBR FIST 2-4, 2024), any ratio | No without test data at that ratio | A mixture can be less resistant to heat (USBR FIST 2-4, 2024) and soften enough to run out of the bearing (ASTM D6185-24, 5.1) |
Centralized lubrication lines, any ratio, ambient temperature | No, flush the lines with one grease | Incompatible mixes cause poor pumpability, which shows up as blocked lines (Fabrico, 2026) |
The first row matters most: without test data for the two products at the ratio in service, the verdict for polyurea and lithium complex grease is no.
Why do polyurea and lithium complex compatibility charts disagree?
Polyurea and lithium complex compatibility charts disagree because each chart rates thickener families, while compatibility belongs to a specific pair of products. SKF's rolling bearings catalogue marks polyurea with lithium complex soap as incompatible but polyurea with plain lithium soap as "individual testing required" (SKF, 2018). The US Bureau of Reclamation table rates polyurea incompatible with both lithium and lithium complex (USBR FIST 2-4, 2024). A maintenance software guide puts polyurea in the incompatible or borderline column for lithium complex, marked "case by case" (Fabrico, 2026).
Tested data points the other way for some products. ExxonMobil states that its Polyrex EM greases passed the ASTM D6185 method with a number of its own lithium complex greases (ExxonMobil, product data sheet). That statement covers named products, not polyurea as a class.
ASTM gives the reason plainly: "Compatibility cannot be predicted with certainty from foreknowledge of grease composition" (ASTM D6185-24, 5.2.2). A chart rating is a screening filter; the D6185 result for your two products is the verdict. Elastomer charts have the same limit, which is why seals can fail when the compatibility chart says compatible.
Does the type of polyurea thickener change compatibility with lithium complex?
The type of polyurea thickener does change compatibility with lithium complex. Polyurea is a chemical class made from different reactants, not one fixed thickener. Fabrico notes that some polyurea thickeners are fully compatible with lithium and lithium complex while others are flatly incompatible (Fabrico, 2026), and Reliable Media states that polyurea covers multiple formulations (ReliaMag, 2026).
Makers also separate their own polyurea grades. ExxonMobil describes the Polyrex EM thickener as an advanced polyurea with increased durability versus conventional polyurea greases under mechanical shear (ExxonMobil, product data sheet), and Fabrico's chart lists conventional polyurea, in particular, as incompatible or borderline with calcium sulfonate (Fabrico, 2026). So a D6185 pass for one polyurea grade says nothing about a different polyurea from another maker.
ABB's low voltage motor manual lists polyurea-based greases for high speed cast iron motors that "can be used for high speed cast iron motors but not mixed with lithium complex greases" (ABB, 2009).
Ask the maker which lithium complex greases it has tested under D6185. Lubinpla's compatibility assessment reads the thickener and base oil composition from the two products' own documents, not their names, and returns a verdict with the mix ratio and temperature attached.
How do you purge polyurea grease before relubricating with lithium complex?
To purge polyurea grease before relubricating with lithium complex, remove as much old grease as the equipment allows, then shorten relubrication intervals until only the new grease comes out. The US Bureau of Reclamation recommends thoroughly cleaning the bearing housing to remove all of the old grease when changing grease type (USBR FIST 2-4, 2024). Where that is not possible, it recommends flushing out as much old grease as possible with the new grease and increasing greasing frequency until the old grease is purged.
Record both thickener types by asset from the technical data sheets.
Where the equipment manual allows disassembly, clean the housing and repack with lithium complex grease, following the manual's procedure and the grease safety data sheet for handling.
Where disassembly is not practical, open the relief or drain port and pump new grease until clean lithium complex grease appears at the outlet.
Shorten the next relubrication intervals, inspect the purged grease for softening, oil separation or leakage, and watch bearing temperature.
ASTM D6185-24 treats the 10:90 and 90:10 ratios as the mixtures likely during flushing, and incompatibility sometimes appears only at those dilute ratios (ASTM D6185-24, 5.3 and 5.3.1). A purge-through changeover, where new grease pushes the old out, is not a safe mix by itself.
Frequently asked questions
What happens in a bearing when polyurea and lithium complex grease mix?
An incompatible mixture most often softens, sometimes enough to run out of an operating bearing, and occasionally hardens or separates into oil and thickener (ASTM D6185-24, 5.1). SKF warns that the consistency of the mix can change dramatically, so severe leakage can damage the bearing (SKF, 2018). STLE readers reported polyurea and lithium complex mixes thinning and leaking out of bearings (STLE TLT, 2013).
How does ASTM D6185 test a polyurea and lithium complex mixture?
ASTM D6185-24 blends the two greases at 10:90, 50:50 and 90:10 and compares each mixture with the neat (unmixed) greases on dropping point (D566 or D2265), shear stability by 100,000-stroke worked penetration (D217) and storage stability at elevated temperature by change in 60-stroke penetration (D217). One failure in any mixture makes the pair incompatible.
Can a 50:50 compatibility test alone clear polyurea and lithium complex grease?
No. ASTM D6185-24 says incompatibility is most often revealed at 50:50, but in some instances 50:50 mixtures are compatible and more dilute ratios are incompatible (ASTM D6185-24, 5.3.1). Ask for results at 10:90 and 90:10 as well.