Lubinpla

Coating defect photos to take before you file a claim

Summary

Documenting a coating failure for a claim takes six steps: overview, scaled close-ups, batch labels, substrate and preparation, untouched condition, and dated records. Take them before any repair or cleaning, with a scale in every close-up, so a reviewer can rate the defects against ASTM D610, ASTM D714 or ISO 4628 from the photos.

  • ASTM D610-25 evaluates the degree of rusting on a zero to ten scale based on the percentage of visible surface rust (ASTM, 2025).

  • ISO 4628-2:2016 provides pictorial standards for blisters in sizes 2, 3, 4 and 5, each in quantities 2, 3, 4 and 5 (ISO, 2016).

  • When ASTM D714-25 reference standards are used as a performance specification, the permissible degree of blistering is agreed between purchaser and seller (ASTM, 2025).

  • ISO 4628-3:2024 estimates the rusted area of a coated surface and does not include edges (ISO, 2024).

This photo set is for organic and duplex coatings on steel structures, tanks and equipment where a supplier or applicator will assess a failure claim. It does not replace an on-site inspection by a coating inspector, laboratory analysis of the failed film, or the evidence list in a specific warranty, which takes precedence where it asks for more.

What do you need before photographing a coating failure?

Before photographing a coating failure, you need a camera with the date and time set correctly, a rigid ruler or scale card, a label card, a light source, and the coating's product data sheet and application records. The scale goes into every close-up, so the size of blisters, cracks or flaking can be read from the photo. The label card gives the site, structure, area code and date in writing, so a photo moved out of its folder still says where it came from.

Check the camera clock against a known time before the first shot. A photo's date is only as accurate as that clock, and the reviewer will compare it with the failure notice and the warranty period.

Bring the documents that tell you what to look for. The product data sheet gives the coating system, film build (coating thickness) and surface preparation the product was specified for. The application records name the batches used and the dates they went on.

If the failure sits at height or in a live process area, plan access before you go. Follow the site's permit and safety rules there: a photo set does not justify an unplanned entry.

Which overall shots show where a coating failure sits on the structure?

Overall shots of a coating failure show the whole structure first, then the failed area within it, so a reviewer can judge how much of the surface is affected and where. Take one wide photo of the structure from a fixed, repeatable point. Then move closer and frame the failed zone with a recognizable feature in view: a nozzle, weld seam, nameplate, support or corner. Shoot each overview from at least two directions.

Extent is part of the rating. ASTM D610-25 evaluates the degree of rusting on a zero to ten scale based on the percentage of visible surface rust, and classifies its distribution as spot, general, pinpoint or hybrid rust (ASTM, 2025). A close-up of one rust spot can show neither the percentage nor the distribution. The overview has to.

Overviews also show the pattern of failure, which can point to a cause. Failure confined to the sun-facing side, the bottom of a tank shell, the area below a drip line, or welds and edges reads differently from failure spread evenly over the surface.

ISO 4628-3:2024 estimates the affected area and states that edges are not included (ISO, 2024), so photograph edges and welds as their own set instead of leaving them inside an area rating.

Mark each overview with the area codes you will use on the close-ups, so every detail photo can be traced back to its place on the structure.

How do you photograph coating defects close up so their size can be rated?

Close-up photos of coating defects can be rated for size when a scale sits in the same plane as the defect and the camera faces the surface square on. Place a ruler or scale card beside the defect, not in front of it, and fill most of the frame with the two. Then take a second shot with light from the side to bring out relief such as blisters, cracks or lifting edges.

Rating works by comparing what you see with written definitions and reference pictures. ISO 4628-1:2016 defines a system for designating the quantity and size of defects (ISO, 2016), and ISO 4628-2:2016 provides pictorial standards for blisters in sizes 2, 3, 4 and 5, each in quantities 2, 3, 4 and 5 (ISO, 2016). ASTM D714-25 uses photographic reference standards to describe the size and density of blisters so that comparisons of severity can be made (ASTM, 2025). A reviewer can place your photo against those references only if the scale is readable.

Photograph several representative defects in each area, not only the worst one, and note the area code of each.

Describe each defect in words too. ASTM D610-25 states that in a dispute the written definition prevails over its visual examples (ASTM, 2025), so the photo log should give each defect's type, size, number and location.

Which labels and batch numbers should appear in coating claim photos?

Coating claim photos should include every container label still available, showing the product name, batch or lot number, and manufacture or expiry date. For a two-component product, photograph the base and curing agent labels separately. Shoot each label flat and in focus with its container beside it, so the label is tied to a real container.

Then add the records that link those batches to the failed area. Photograph or scan the application record, daily report or work sheet showing which batch went onto which area on which date, along with any recorded conditions such as air and steel temperature, relative humidity and dew point. A batch label without that link proves only that the product existed, not that it was applied where the coating failed.

Put a label card in the overview and close-up photos too. With the site, structure, area code and date in the frame, the photo stays identifiable when it is forwarded, printed or renamed, and the coating maker can match each picture to the claim form. Further reading on getting every engineer to record site visits with the same fields: how to make every customer visit report follow one template.

Why photograph the substrate and surface preparation under a failed coating?

Photographs of the substrate and surface preparation under a failed coating show whether the failure started at the steel, inside the coating system or at its surface. A coating claim often turns on that point. Where the coating has flaked or peeled, photograph the underside of a loose flake and the surface it came off, with a scale, before anything is cleaned.

Mill scale, rust, old paint, dust or a smooth surface under the film point toward preparation. Clean, roughened steel under a coating that split within its own layers points elsewhere.

ISO 8501-1:2007 specifies rust grades and preparation grades of steel surfaces, defined by written descriptions together with photographs that are representative examples of each grade (ISO, 2007). The grades describe the visual cleanliness of uncoated steel, or of steel after overall removal of previous coatings, before painting (ISO, 2007); they do not rate surface profile (roughness). Treat the photo as a visual comparison with those grades. A sharp photo allows that comparison, but it is weaker evidence than an on-site inspection. Add the surface preparation inspection records made at application, such as cleanliness grade and profile readings, if they exist. As of 2026-10-23, ISO lists ISO 8501-1:2007 as expected to be replaced by ISO/DIS 8501-1 (ISO, 2026).

Do not cut, scrape or pull the coating for a better picture unless the coating maker agrees. A destructive check changes the evidence, and the maker may want its own representative there when it is done.

What should you photograph before a failed coating is repaired or removed?

Before a failed coating is repaired or removed, photograph every failed area in its untouched condition, including defects you do not plan to claim. Once the area is touched up, washed, blasted or stripped, the photos are the only record of how the coating failed. Nobody can rate rusting or blistering on a surface that no longer exists.

ASTM D610-25 states that the amount of rusting beneath or through a paint film is a significant factor in determining whether a coating system should be repaired or replaced (ASTM, 2025). That decision, and the claim behind it, depends on a rating of the coating made before the repair.

If a repair cannot wait, notify the coating maker or supplier first and keep a copy of the notice with the photos.

When the repair has to go ahead for safety or production reasons, photograph each stage: the failed condition, the area marked out for repair, the removed material and the substrate once exposed. If site rules allow it, keep a labeled sample of the failed coating, since laboratory analysis may need it later.

When the work is finished, take a dated photo of the repaired area. It is the starting point if the coating fails again.

How do you check that a coating claim photo set is complete?

Check a coating claim photo set against the table below before sending it. Each row should pass for every failed area. Together the rows decide whether a reviewer can locate and rate the coating failure from the photos, and they narrow what a site inspection still has to settle.

Shot

What it must show

What it lets the reviewer decide

Fail and what to do

Overview

Whole structure and failed zone from a fixed point, two directions

Extent and distribution, such as spot, general, pinpoint or hybrid rust (ASTM D610-25)

Zone cannot be located: retake with a fixed feature in frame

Close-up with scale

Defect and readable scale, square on, plus side lighting

Size and quantity against reference pictures (ISO 4628-2:2016, ASTM D714-25)

Scale unreadable or angled: retake with the scale beside the defect

Label and batch

Product name, batch number and dates for each component

Which batch the claim concerns

Label missing: photograph the delivery note or application record

Substrate and preparation

Underside of flakes and exposed surface, with scale

Preparation against rust and preparation grades (ISO 8501-1:2007)

Area already cleaned: state this in writing; do not recreate it

Before repair

Every failed area untouched, including unclaimed ones

How the coating failed

Already repaired: record the date and what was done

Date and location

Label card in frame, camera clock checked

Timeline against the notice and warranty dates

Clock wrong: record the offset in the photo log

The close-up row settles most rating questions. Without a readable scale in the same plane as the defect, a reviewer cannot place it against the ISO 4628-2 or ASTM D714 reference pictures.

Check the set again when the reviewer's first questions come back. A request for a missing angle or label is cheaper to answer while the failed area is still untouched.

Send the coating claim photos with a short photo log that lists each file name, area code, date and what it shows. In Lubinpla, the photos can be attached to the visit's work log, so they stay with the visit record and the technical lead can review them through comments.

Frequently asked questions

Can phone photos be used for a coating claim?

Phone photos can support a coating claim when they are sharp, include a readable scale, and are sent as original files with their dates intact. Check the claim form or warranty for format rules first. Messaging apps may compress images and strip file dates, so send the originals by email or file transfer.

How many photos does a coating failure claim need?

No standard fixes a number of photos for a coating failure claim. A complete set has at least two overviews per failed area, a scaled close-up of each defect type in each area, every available label, and the exposed substrate where the coating has come off. Missing areas matter more than the total count.

Should dry film thickness readings be photographed for a coating claim?

Yes, if dry film thickness was measured on the failed coating, photograph the gauge display next to the spot measured, with the area code card in frame. Record the gauge model and the measurement method named in the coating specification, so the reviewer can compare the readings with the film build on the product data sheet.

Related posts