Lubinpla

How to read the ASTM D1654 rating scale against a spec

Summary

ASTM D1654-24e1 rates creep from a scribe on coated panels from 10 (no creep) to 0 (over 16 mm), and the specification sets the pass line. As of 29 October 2026 ASTM lists D1654-24e1 as active (ASTM, 2024). Read mean and maximum creep against the limit, then check blister and rust grades.

  • ASTM lists D1654-24e1 as the active edition of the scribe evaluation method, and D1654-08(2016)e1 as historical (ASTM, 2024).

  • One published coating test method sets a minimum acceptable D1654 rating of 5 after 1000 hours of salt spray, with one-sided creep measured from the scribe line (DuPont, 2007).

  • A 2000 ASTM symposium paper found that the percentage of delaminated area correlated well and linearly with D1654 ratings (Warburton and Gibbon, 2000).

  • A 1991 comparison with two-year on-vehicle tests found ASTM B117 salt spray unsuitable for ranking the cosmetic corrosion of coated steel sheet (Townsend et al., 1991).

This answer covers reading D1654 scribe creep ratings on coated metal panels against a written specification after salt spray, cyclic or outdoor exposure. It does not cover how to scribe panels or run the cabinet, and it does not reproduce the D1654 rating table. The millimeter bands quoted here come from a published reproduction of an earlier edition, so confirm them in your copy of D1654-24e1.

What does an ASTM D1654 scribe creep rating measure?

An ASTM D1654 scribe creep rating measures how far corrosion and loss of adhesion spread under a coating after corrosive exposure, starting from the scribe: a deliberate scratch cut through the coating to the metal. ASTM D1654-24e1 covers the evaluation of painted or coated specimens "in respect to corrosion, blistering associated with corrosion, loss of adhesion at a scribe mark, or other film failure" (ASTM, 2024). ASTM describes its purpose as "evaluating and comparing basic corrosion performance of the substrate, pretreatment, or coating system, or combination thereof" (ASTM, 2024).

In practice a technician scribes an X or a straight line through the coating to the substrate, exposes the panel to humidity, salt spray or cyclic corrosion, then removes the loosened coating and measures how far corrosion travelled from the scribe in millimeters (ATS, accessed 23 October 2026). That distance is the creep. One published coating test method defines scribe creepage as one sided, "from the original scribe line to the creepage front" (DuPont, 2007).

A rating describes one panel after one exposure. On its own it is not a verdict. ASTM D1654 sets no exposure period and no pass line, and the companion salt spray practice, ASTM B117-26a, "does not prescribe the type of test specimen or exposure periods to be used for a specific product, nor the interpretation to be given to the results" (ASTM, 2026). The hours and the minimum rating come from the coating specification or purchase agreement, so a D1654 rating means something only next to that document.

What does each step of the ASTM D1654 rating scale mean in millimeters?

Each step of the ASTM D1654 rating scale stands for a band of one-sided creep in millimeters, and the bands widen as the rating falls. The scale runs from 10, no creep, to 0, creep of more than 16 mm (ATS, accessed 23 October 2026). A 2007 US patent from DuPont reproduced the bands of the edition then in use: 9 for up to 0.5 mm, 8 for 0.5 to 1.0 mm, 7 for 1.0 to 2.0 mm, 6 for 2.0 to 3.0 mm, 5 for 3.0 to 5.0 mm, 4 for 5.0 to 7.0 mm, 3 for 7.0 to 10.0 mm, 1 for 13.0 to 16.0 mm and 0 for 16.0 mm and above, with a 10.0 to 13.0 mm band between 3 and 1 (DuPont, 2007).

Three things follow when you read a rating against a limit. First, the scale is not linear. Near the top one rating step is 0.5 mm wide, while the step from 6 to 5 spans 2 mm. A one-point drop at the low end therefore hides more corrosion.

Second, a rating is a band, not a value. A panel rated 5 can have 3.1 mm or 4.9 mm of creep, so report the millimeters with the rating.

Third, the bands above come from an earlier edition reproduced in a patent, not from D1654-24e1 itself. ASTM lists the 2024 edition with an editorial correction as active (ASTM, 2024), so check the bands in your licensed copy before you set or read a limit.

How do you read a scribe creep rating against a coating specification?

Read a scribe creep rating against a coating specification in three checks, in this order: the run is valid, the creep value the specification names meets its limit, and the other ratings the specification lists also pass. The table below gives what each combination of results means and what to do next. Its limit values are examples from one published coating test method, not general D1654 limits.

Result

Meaning

Action

Mean and maximum creep inside the limit; blister and rust grades pass

Panel meets the scribe criterion, for example a minimum rating of 5 at 1000 hours (DuPont, 2007)

Record rating, millimeters, hours, exposure method and D1654 edition

Mean creep passes, maximum creep fails

Local undercutting at one point of the scribe

Report both values; judge on the value the specification names; record the maximum as a separate finding

Rating exactly at the limit, such as 5 against a minimum of 5

Meets "minimum rating" wording, but rating 5 covers 3.0 to 5.0 mm (DuPont, 2007)

Report the millimeters and the spread of replicate panels

Creep passes, blister (ASTM D714) or rust (ASTM D610) grade fails

Coating fails the specification if it lists those grades

Report the failing grade beside the passing creep; do not average it away

Control panel outside its usual range, or scribe not through to metal

Run is not valid

Do not judge the coating; rescribe or repeat the exposure

The row that needs the most care is the panel exactly at the limit. A rating of 5 meets a minimum of 5, yet the measured creep can sit anywhere from 3.0 to 5.0 mm (DuPont, 2007). Only the millimeter value and the replicates show how much margin the coating really has.

In practice, read the last row first: an invalid run stops the evaluation before any scribe creep rating is judged. When mean creep passes and maximum creep fails, the specification's wording settles the call, not the laboratory's preference.

Should you report mean or maximum scribe creep against a spec limit?

Report both mean and maximum scribe creep and judge against whichever one the specification names, because ASTM D1654 creep is rarely even along a scribe. A 2000 ASTM symposium paper stated the problem directly: "At times when the width along the scribe is not uniform, it is difficult to apply this standard" (Warburton and Gibbon, 2000). The authors explained that the standard "is attempting to describe a two-dimensional pattern with a linear parameter" (Warburton and Gibbon, 2000).

Mean creep averages the whole scribe. One 2024 patent that rated panels to D1654-08 measured the mean width of creepage in millimeters, and defined mean creepage as the area of rust creepage divided by twice the scribe length, following ASTM D7087-05a (Cirrus Materials Science, 2024). Maximum creep is the single widest point, often at a scribe end, a panel edge or a local defect.

When the specification names one value, judge on that value. When it is silent, agree before exposure which value governs, so the choice cannot follow the results.

A panel whose mean passes while one point exceeds the limit is not a clean pass. It suggests a local weakness, such as poor pretreatment at that spot, that can matter in service. Report the maximum and its location as a separate finding beside the verdict on the governing value, and photograph the scribe so a reviewer can see the shape of the creep.

How do blister and rust ratings change a passing scribe creep result?

Blister and rust ratings change a passing scribe creep result when the specification lists them. A coating can hold well at the scribe and still blister or rust across the panel face.

Specifications commonly pair the methods: one supplier coating standard calls for salt spray "In accordance with ASTM B117 w/ASTM D1654 scribe and ASTM D714, Blister Grade" (Viasat, rev. 003, accessed 2026). The DuPont test method rated blister size and frequency to ASTM D714 alongside the D1654 scribe rating (DuPont, 2007).

ASTM D714-25 rates blister size and density against photographic references, and its scope says that when they "are used as a specification of performance, the permissible degree of blistering of the paint system shall be agreed upon by the purchaser and the seller" (ASTM, 2025). The blister limit is therefore a contract value, like the creep limit.

ASTM D610-25 rates visible rust on painted steel, but it "does not include evaluation of rust propagation around an initially prepared scribe, score, or holiday" (ASTM, 2025). Rust grade covers the panel face; D1654 covers the scribe. Read each against its own limit and report every grade, so a passing creep rating is never presented as the whole result.

If the specification names only creep, blistering or face rust is still worth reporting as a finding. It shows a weakness that the creep rating does not capture.

When is an ASTM D1654 scribe creep result not valid?

An ASTM D1654 scribe creep result is not valid when the scribe, the exposure or the comparison panels do not meet the conditions the test depends on. Three checks catch this, and the first is the scribe.

Q-Lab notes that "differences in scribe depth can significantly affect" cyclic corrosion test results, especially on galvanized substrates, that in most cases the scribe should penetrate into the base metal, and that the specific scribe tool should be reported because scribe geometry can also affect results (Q-Lab, 2009). A scribe that stops in the primer or zinc layer measures a different failure.

The second check is the run itself. ASTM D5894-21 advises against a pass or fail approval after a set exposure "unless performance comparisons are made relative to a control material exposed simultaneously, or the variability in the test is rigorously quantified" (ASTM, 2021). A control panel, a known system run in the same cabinet, shows whether the run was harsher or milder than usual. If the control rates far outside its usual range, the run says more about the cabinet than about the coating.

The third check is the record: exposure method and hours, D1654 edition, number of replicate panels and whether creep was measured one sided. Withhold judgment on an invalid run rather than reporting it as a failure; the same logic for whole plant trials is set out in how to tell whether a failed plant trial was valid at all.

Why do scribe creep results from salt spray and cyclic tests rank coatings differently?

Scribe creep results from salt spray and cyclic tests rank coatings differently because continuous salt fog does not reproduce the wet and dry cycles that drive corrosion under a coating in service. ASTM B117-26a states that "Prediction of performance in natural environments has seldom been correlated with salt spray results when used as stand-alone data" (ASTM, 2026), and that correlation should be considered only where corroborating long-term atmospheric exposures have been conducted (ASTM, 2026).

Field data back the warning. A 1991 study by the American Iron and Steel Institute task force compared four cyclic laboratory tests with two-year on-vehicle tests in St. John's and Montreal. It found that the cyclic tests gave a good correlation with scribe creep of coated sheet in the vehicle test, but underestimated creep on cold rolled steel, and called B117 "totally unsuitable for ranking the cosmetic corrosion resistance of coated steel sheet products" (Townsend et al., 1991). Q-Lab reports that cyclic tests usually give better correlation to outdoors than conventional salt spray (Q-Lab, 2009).

Cyclic tests are not a field forecast either. ASTM D5894-21 says its results represent outdoor exposure "only when the degree of rank correlation has been established for the specific materials being tested", and advises against converting laboratory hours into outdoor months (ASTM, 2021). A D1654 rating is strongest as a comparison between coatings in the same test, not a service-life prediction.

Common mistakes when reading ASTM D1654 scribe creep ratings

Most mistakes in reading ASTM D1654 scribe creep ratings come from comparing numbers that were not measured the same way. Five recur.

First, mixing one-sided and total creep. One published coating test method defines creep from the scribe line to the creepage front on one side (DuPont, 2007). A lab that reports total width across the scribe gives roughly double the number for the same panel, so state which one is reported.

Second, comparing ratings from different runs or cabinets. ASTM D5894-21 states that it is not recommended to compare degradation of materials exposed for the same duration at separate times or in separate devices (ASTM, 2021). Compare a candidate with a same-run control.

Third, quoting a rating without the exposure. A rating of 7 after 250 hours and a 7 after 1000 hours describe different coatings, and the DuPont test method checked panels after each 250 hour period up to 1000 hours (DuPont, 2007).

Fourth, using ASTM D610 rust grades for the scribe. D610 excludes rust propagation around a scribe (ASTM, 2025).

Fifth, reading the rating band as a measurement. Rating 5 spans 3.0 to 5.0 mm in the published bands (DuPont, 2007), so record the millimeters as well.

What should you use alongside an ASTM D1654 rating?

Alongside an ASTM D1654 rating, use a measured creep value, an area or image method for uneven creep, the ISO method for international specifications, and blister and rust grades on the panel face. For uneven creep, the 2000 ASTM symposium paper proposed delaminated area measured by image analysis, which correlated well and linearly with D1654 ratings (Warburton and Gibbon, 2000). ASTM later issued D7087, an imaging method to measure rust creepage area from a scribe, but BSI lists ASTM D7087-05a(2010) as withdrawn on 17 January 2019 (BSI, 2019), so cite it only as background.

For international work, ISO 4628-8:2012, listed as valid by the Swedish Institute for Standards, "specifies a method for assessing delamination and corrosion around a scribe or other artificial defect on a coated panel" (SIS, 2012). A specification written to ISO 4628-8 cannot be read with a D1654 rating, so convert only through measured millimeters and the definitions in each standard.

Photographs of each scribe at each inspection let a reviewer check the call later. Lubinpla's test result evaluation brings the same discipline to your own test reports and specifications: it compares each result with criteria fixed in advance and records any shortfall that could change the conclusion as a separate finding.

Key takeaways

  • ASTM D1654-24e1 is the active edition. It rates creep from a scribe from 10 (none) to 0 (over 16 mm) and sets no pass line of its own.

  • The specification supplies the exposure hours and the minimum rating; read the rating only against that document.

  • Rating bands widen as the rating falls, so record the measured millimeters with every rating.

  • Report mean and maximum creep, judge on the named value and record the other as a finding.

  • A passing creep rating does not clear the panel if ASTM D714 blister or ASTM D610 rust grades fail.

  • Check scribe depth, a same-run control panel and one-sided measurement before judging.

  • Treat salt spray creep as a comparison in one test, not a field-life forecast.

Related posts