Lubinpla

Cross-Hatch Adhesion Test Results: 4B vs 5B Pass Criteria

Summary

ASTM D3359-23 rates tape-test adhesion from 5B to 0B but sets no pass mark, so 4B passes only when the agreed specification accepts it. As of 23 October 2026, D3359-23 is the active edition (ASTM, 2023). Its published scope judges adequacy "for the user's application", which puts the passing rating in the customer or product specification, fixed before testing.

  • ASTM D3359-23 is the active edition of the tape adhesion test, last updated on 7 March 2023 (ASTM, 2023).

  • Test Method B, the cross-hatch lattice, is primarily intended for coatings under 125 µm (5 mils) total thickness; Test Method A, the X-cut, for thicker systems (ASTM, 2023).

  • On the ASTM Method B chart, 5B means 0% of the lattice area removed and 4B means less than 5% affected (DeFelsko manual, accessed 2026).

  • ISO 2409:2020 runs the other way, with 0 as the best class, and the method is not suitable for coatings over 250 µm total thickness (DeFelsko manual, accessed 2026; ISO 2409:2020).

This answer covers reading and accepting ASTM D3359 Method B and ISO 2409 cross-hatch results on organic coatings over metal. It does not cover how to cut and tape the lattice, X-cut ratings on thick systems, or coatings on wood and plastic, where ASTM notes that precision data are lacking.

What does the ASTM D3359 cross-hatch adhesion test measure, and how?

The ASTM D3359 cross-hatch adhesion test checks whether a coating resists removal by pressure-sensitive tape after a lattice of cuts has been made through the film to the metal. ASTM D3359-23 covers "procedures for assessing the adhesion of relatively ductile coating films to metallic substrates by applying and removing pressure-sensitive tape over cuts made in the film" (ASTM, 2023). Test Method B is the cross-hatch version and is primarily intended for coating systems under 125 µm (5 mils) total thickness; Test Method A, the X-cut, is primarily intended for systems over 125 µm (ASTM, 2023).

Film thickness sets the cutter spacing. A DeFelsko guide to Method B gives a 1 mm, 11-tooth blade for 0 to 50 µm (0 to 2 mils) and a 2 mm, 6-tooth blade for 50 to 125 µm (2 to 5 mils), and states that all cuts must reach the substrate or the test is invalid (DeFelsko, 2023). Once the tape is pulled, the operator compares the lattice with the ASTM classification chart and assigns one class, from 5B to 0B (DeFelsko, 2023).

The result tells you less than it may seem to. ASTM states that the methods do not give an absolute value for the force needed to break the bond, but serve "only as an indicator that some minimum value for bond strength was met or exceeded" (ASTM, 2023). A cross-hatch rating is a threshold check on one panel or part, not a measurement of adhesion strength.

What does a 4B versus a 5B cross-hatch rating mean?

A 5B cross-hatch rating means no coating came off the lattice. A 4B rating means small flakes came off at the cut intersections, over less than 5% of the lattice area. The ASTM Method B chart, as reproduced in the DeFelsko PosiTest CH manual, describes 5B as cut edges "completely smooth; none of the squares of the lattice is detached" and 4B as "small flakes of the coating are detached at intersections; less than 5% of the area is affected" (DeFelsko manual, accessed 2026).

The table below assumes the acceptance rating was written into the specification before testing, and gives what each cross-hatch result means and what to do next.

Cross-hatch result

Meaning

Action

5B

No lattice area removed (DeFelsko manual, accessed 2026)

Accept against any agreed rating; record method, spacing and tape

4B

Flakes at intersections, under 5% of area (DeFelsko manual, accessed 2026)

Accept only if the specification states 4B or lower as the minimum

3B or lower

5 to 15% of area affected at 3B, more at 2B to 0B (DeFelsko manual, accessed 2026)

Reject against a 4B or 5B specification; investigate pretreatment and cure

Removal down to bare metal

Failure at the coating to substrate interface

Check surface preparation and pretreatment before the coating itself

Removal between coats

Intercoat failure; substrate adhesion not determined (ASTM, 2023)

Report the interface; review recoat window and intercoat cleanliness

Result differs between two operators or tapes

Within known method variability (ASTM, 2023)

Record both as a separate finding; retest under the agreed plan

The row that decides most cases is 4B: it passes only where the specification names 4B as acceptable, and it fails a specification that requires 5B. In ISO 2409 terms the same two lattices are class 0 and class 1 (DeFelsko manual, accessed 2026), so the specification must also say which scale its minimum rating refers to.

Why does ASTM D3359 not define a passing cross-hatch rating?

ASTM D3359 sets no passing rating because it is a test method: it rates adhesion and leaves the judgment of adequacy to the user's application. The scope of ASTM D3359-23 states: "These test methods are used to evaluate whether the adhesion of a coating to a substrate is adequate for the user's application" (ASTM, 2023). Neither its published scope nor its significance section names any rating as a pass.

The method also explains why a single pass mark would mislead. ASTM states that the test "is insensitive to all but large differences in adhesion" and that limiting the rankings to 0 to 5 reflects its inability to make fine distinctions (ASTM, 2023). A coating on a cabinet panel and a coating on a structural member carry different service loads, so the same rating can be adequate for one and not for the other.

ISO standards take the same position. ISO 2409:2020 can be used "either as a pass/fail test or, where circumstances are appropriate, as a six-step classification test", which leaves the choice of form to the user (ISO 2409:2020). ISO 16276-2:2025, which sets inspection areas, sampling plans and acceptance or rejection criteria for protective paint systems on steel structures, still "does not specify ratings for particular coating systems" (ISO 16276-2:2025). The rating that passes always comes from a document outside the test method.

How do you set the cross-hatch acceptance rating before testing?

You set the cross-hatch acceptance rating before testing by writing the method, the conditions and the minimum rating into the customer or product specification. Each result is then judged against a fixed rule. ISO 16276-2:2025 makes this a precondition: it "is only applicable if the cross-cut or X-cut test method is specified, together with the rating from the appropriate rating scale" (ISO 16276-2:2025).

A usable acceptance clause names these items, in this order:

  1. The standard and edition, such as ASTM D3359-23 Method B or ISO 2409:2020, and the rating scale that applies.

  2. The film thickness range, measured first by a practice such as ASTM D7091-22, because the method and the cut spacing depend on it (ASTM, 2023).

  3. The cut spacing and the tape, named by product and lot or by adhesion strength, since one tape may not adhere equally well to different coatings (ASTM, 2023).

  4. The test conditions, because extremes in temperature or relative humidity may affect the adhesion of the tape or the coating (ASTM, 2023).

  5. The number of tests and their locations, and the minimum rating each must reach, such as "4B or better at every location" (illustrative).

  6. The failure interface that fails the part, and how a borderline or disputed result is handled.

ASTM D4541-22 applies the same logic to pull-off tests: the purchaser or specifier "shall designate" the procedure and protocol (ASTM, 2022).

How should a borderline cross-hatch adhesion result be handled?

Record a borderline cross-hatch adhesion result as a separate finding with its conditions, retest under the agreed plan, and judge it only against the rating fixed before testing. A result is borderline when the operator finds the lattice hard to place between two classes, such as 4B and 5B, or when two operators rate the same panel differently.

ASTM D3359-23 expects this kind of spread. It states that "it is not unexpected that different operators might obtain different results", and that the angle and rate of tape removal and the visual assessment depend on operator skill (ASTM, 2023). It also notes that variation in pull rate and peel angle can cause large differences in test values (ASTM, 2023).

Two rules keep the decision honest. First, do not split the difference: ASTM states that "users shall not use intermediate values for ranking adhesion tests within this method" (ASTM, 2023), so a "4.5B" is not a valid result. Second, do not move the acceptance line after seeing the result. If the specification says 5B and one location rates 4B, the part fails that location; a waiver is a separate, documented decision by the specification owner. For how to report a trial that meets some criteria and misses others, see what to do when a chemical trial result only partly passes.

With each borderline finding, record the operator, tape lot, film thickness, interface and photographs of the lattice, so a second reviewer can rate the same evidence.

Why can a 5B cross-hatch result not rank two coatings?

A 5B cross-hatch result cannot rank two coatings because the method only shows that a minimum bond was reached; it cannot separate coatings whose adhesion lies above that level. ASTM D3359-23 states that the methods "do not distinguish between higher levels of adhesion for which more sophisticated methods of measurement are required" (ASTM, 2023). Two coatings that both rate 5B may differ widely in bond strength, and the tape test will not show it.

Supplier data has the same limit. A 5B on a technical data sheet and a 5B in your own test mean only that both coatings met the same threshold, possibly under different tapes, thicknesses and conditions. ASTM notes that a given tape may not adhere equally well to different coatings because of differences in composition and topology (ASTM, 2023), so a 5B on one coating and a 5B on another are not the same measurement.

To rank coatings that both pass the cross-hatch test, use a quantitative method. ASTM D4541-22 determines "the greatest perpendicular force (in tension) that a surface area can bear before a plug of material is detached" (ASTM, 2022), and ISO 4624:2023 notes that pull-off methods are "most useful in providing relative ratings for a series of coated panels exhibiting significant differences in adhesion" (ISO 4624:2023). Keep the same pull-off instrument and procedure across the coatings, since D4541-22 states that results should not be compared across instruments (ASTM, 2022).

Why do published cross-hatch rating scales and pass marks differ?

Published cross-hatch rating scales and pass marks differ for three reasons: the two standards number the classes in opposite directions, secondary sources simplify the scale, and pass marks come from product documents rather than from the test method. ASTM D3359 runs from 5B, the best, to 0B, while ISO 2409 runs from 0, the best, to 5 (DeFelsko manual, accessed 2026). A Powder Coating Institute article warns that this "underscores the need to be very careful in citing your test method when reporting results" (PCI, 2018). An ISO class 1 and an ASTM 4B describe the same lattice, so a report that says only "1" can be read as a near pass or as a near total failure.

Some test lab pages compress the scale. One laboratory page states that ASTM D3359 results "range from 1B to 5B" and are "either pass or fail" (ATS, accessed 2026). D3359-23 itself describes rankings from 0 to 5 (ASTM, 2023) and names no pass mark in its published scope.

Pass marks vary with the document that sets them. A 2023 coating patent states that "adhesion ratings of 5B, preferably no less than 4B, are typically desired for commercially viable coatings", and its claim uses at least 4B by ASTM D3359-95 (Swimc, 2023). That is one applicant's target for its own invention, not a general rule. Do not copy a pass mark from a web page or a patent into a specification; agree it with the customer for the product and service.

Common mistakes when reading cross-hatch adhesion results

Most mistakes in reading cross-hatch adhesion results come from treating the rating as a measurement, or from changing the rules after the test. Six come up again and again:

  1. Reading an ISO 2409 class 0 as a failure, or an ASTM 0B as a pass, because nobody stated the scale direction.

  2. Using Method B on films over 125 µm (5 mils) total thickness, which ASTM D3359-23 does not consider suitable unless wider-spaced cuts are used and purchaser and seller explicitly agree (ASTM, 2023).

  3. Reporting a rating without the failure interface. In multicoat systems, ASTM notes, failure may occur between coats, so substrate adhesion is not determined (ASTM, 2023).

  4. Averaging ratings or writing intermediate values such as 4.5B, which the method forbids for ranking (ASTM, 2023).

  5. Changing the tape between lots or suppliers without noting it, even though tape adhesion varies with the coating (ASTM, 2023).

  6. Ranking two coatings by a shared 5B rating, when the method does not distinguish higher levels of adhesion (ASTM, 2023).

A DeFelsko summary of the ASTM reporting items lists the substrate, coating type, cure method, number of tests with mean and range, tape identity, and an estimate of the failure interface (DeFelsko, 2023). With these items in the report, a second reader can check whether the rating was read correctly, and most of the six mistakes above never happen.

What to use alongside the cross-hatch adhesion test

Alongside the cross-hatch adhesion test, check dry film thickness before cutting, and run a pull-off test when you need a number. ASTM D7091-22 describes magnetic and eddy current gauges for dry film thickness on metal and states that "the governing specification is responsible for providing the user with the minimum and the maximum coating thickness for each layer, and for the total coating system" (ASTM, 2022). The measured thickness decides whether Method A or Method B applies and which cut spacing to use.

For a quantitative value, ASTM D4541-22 or ISO 4624:2023 pull-off tests report the force at fracture and the plane where it occurred. ASTM D4541-22 warns that results vary when the glue, dolly size, cure time, pull rate or device change (ASTM, 2022), so fix those in the same specification as the cross-hatch rule. For protective coatings on steel structures, ISO 16276-2:2025 adds inspection areas and sampling plans to the cross-cut and X-cut tests (ISO 16276-2:2025).

Every result then goes back to the acceptance criteria written before the test. Lubinpla evaluates a test result only against the criteria fixed before the result came in, records a borderline result as a separate finding, and returns one cited document for your review.

Key takeaways

  • ASTM D3359-23 rates cross-hatch adhesion from 5B to 0B and names no passing rating; adequacy is judged for the user's application.

  • A 4B passes only if the agreed specification accepts 4B; against a 5B requirement it fails.

  • Write the standard, edition, method, thickness range, tape, conditions, sampling and minimum rating into the specification before testing.

  • Record borderline and disputed ratings as separate findings; never use intermediate values.

  • A 5B cannot rank two coatings; use a pull-off test such as ASTM D4541-22 or ISO 4624:2023 for that.

  • State the scale with every result: ISO 2409 class 0 is the best, ASTM 0B the worst.

Related posts