Lubinpla

Why a PTSA tracer reads low when the chemical pump is dosing

Summary

When the pump runs but the PTSA tracer reads low, the usual cause is lost pump delivery, higher blowdown or makeup, or a suppressed fluorometer reading. A product with less PTSA than the meter assumes also reads low. Inhibitor consumption is not a cause, because PTSA is inert. The guide applies to open recirculating cooling towers on a PTSA-traced product.

  • With 0.1 percent PTSA blended in the product, 100 ppb PTSA in the cooling water corresponds to 100 ppm of product (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

  • Because of color, turbidity and makeup background, 30 ppb PTSA is a practical low limit for cooling water readings (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

  • Inhibitor is consumed by doing its job while PTSA is not, so an upset can deplete inhibitor while the PTSA reading stays normal (Walchem, 2020).

  • If cycles of concentration from flow meters exceed cycles from conductivity by more than 10 percent, the tower may be losing water through leaks, overflow or drift (US EPA, 2012).

This guide covers open recirculating cooling towers fed a PTSA-traced inhibitor and read with a PTSA fluorometer. Closed loops share the interference checks but not the blowdown causes. Boilers are outside it, because PTSA hydrolyzes at high pH and elevated temperature (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

What are the most likely causes of a low PTSA tracer reading?

A low PTSA tracer reading with the chemical pump running has four likely causes: the pump is not delivering, water leaves the tower faster, the fluorometer reads low, or the product carries less PTSA than the meter assumes.

Lost pump delivery

A pump that strokes is not always delivering. Treatment pumps can lose prime (Solenis, 2018). An air-bound head, an empty or stratified day tank, a blocked foot valve and a plugged injection quill all look the same: the pump light blinks, but little product reaches the water.

Higher blowdown or makeup

Blowdown is water bled off through the bleed valve, and makeup replaces the water lost. Because PTSA is inert, its level in the tower depends on the product fed and the water removed. A bleed valve stuck open, a lowered conductivity set point, a leak or an overflow dilutes the product even when the feed is correct.

Suppressed fluorometer reading

Color and turbidity attenuate the light and lower the PTSA reading, and quaternary amines and cationic polymers can reduce or totally eliminate it (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

Product tracer ratio

Suppliers can vary PTSA content between products, and the fluorometer converts ppb PTSA to ppm product with a set ratio (Pyxis Lab, 2016). A product change without a matching meter change reads low.

Does a PTSA reading show the inhibitor that is still active?

A PTSA reading does not show the inhibitor that is still active. It shows how much traced product was fed and is still in the water. PTSA is an inert tracer, and its measured concentration "can be used to calculate the theoretical product dosage" (Pyxis Lab, 2016). The inhibitor in the same product, such as a phosphate or a polymer, is consumed by doing its job while PTSA is not (Walchem, 2020).

Two conclusions follow. First, inhibitor consumption cannot lower the PTSA reading. Scale formation, corrosion or deposition takes out active inhibitor, not tracer, so consumption explains failed protection alongside a normal PTSA reading, not a low one. Walchem notes that upset conditions can quickly deplete the inhibitor while the PTSA concentration remains normal (Walchem, 2020).

Second, a low PTSA reading means less product is in the water than the set point assumes, or the instrument reads less than is there. Field trials compared product doses from molybdate, total phosphate or polymer tests with PTSA and found that PTSA tracks the other methods well unless the cooling water is under severe stress (Pyxis Lab, 2016). Under stress the two diverge, and it is the inhibitor that drops while PTSA stays normal (Walchem, 2020).

Can blowdown and makeup changes lower the PTSA reading?

Blowdown and makeup changes can lower the PTSA reading. The product level a tower settles at is set by how fast product goes in against how fast water leaves. If the feed rate of the treatment chemical and the blowdown rate are known, the treatment dosage can in theory be calculated (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

Water leaves an open tower through evaporation, drift, blowdown, and leaks or overflows, and makeup replaces it (US EPA, 2012). Evaporation removes water but not PTSA, so only blowdown, drift, leaks and overflow carry tracer out. Cycles of concentration are approximately equal to the ratio of makeup volume to blowdown volume (US DOE FEMP, n.d.).

How far the reading moves depends on the feed method. With a fixed or timer feed, more blowdown dilutes the product directly: in an illustrative case, doubling blowdown at the same feed rate roughly halves the steady PTSA level. Feed paced to makeup makes the product level follow cycles, so a drop in cycles lowers PTSA in proportion.

The reading also lags. After a blowdown or feed change, the tower drifts to its new level over a period set by system volume and blowdown, so a low value can reflect a change made earlier in the week. Check the conductivity set point, the bleed valve, and the makeup and blowdown meter totals for the same period as the low readings.

What interferes with a PTSA fluorometer reading?

Three things mainly suppress a PTSA fluorometer reading: color and turbidity, cationic chemistry, and, in closed loops, high nitrite. Ozone can destroy PTSA itself. The PTSA measurement uses 365 nm excitation and 410 nm emission and is otherwise described as very reliable (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

Color and turbidity attenuate the excitation and emission light and lower the reading; cooling water color usually comes from iron corrosion products, and filtering the sample usually removes both color and turbidity (Pyxis Lab, 2016). One maker states that uncompensated color and turbidity can cause dosing errors of up to 50 percent, and rates its compensated inline probe for up to 150 NTU turbidity and 4 ppm iron (Pyxis Lab, n.d.).

Quaternary amines and cationic polymers reduce or eliminate the PTSA reading; a quat biocide shot shows as a sharp dip on the trend, and cationic polymer can carry over from makeup pretreatment (Pyxis Lab, 2016). To check, add a drop of concentrated anionic polymer or polymer-containing product to the sample. A significant rise in the PTSA reading means cationic interference is likely (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

In closed loops, nitrite above 500 ppm absorbs at the excitation wavelength and needs checking (Pyxis Lab, 2016). PTSA is stable to common oxidizing biocides at normal dosage, but has been reported to be destroyed in ozone treatment (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

The instrument itself is a fifth cause: a fouled sample cell or a drifted calibration can read low on every sample.

How can you tell low PTSA causes apart at the cooling tower?

Seven checks, each pointing to one cause, separate low PTSA causes at the cooling tower: pump delivery, tank use, blowdown, sample interference, matrix recovery, instrument calibration and an independent inhibitor test. Run them in the table's order, because the first two are quick and test the feed itself.

The table pairs what each check shows with the cause it points to.

Check

What you see

Points to

Drawdown volume from a calibration column over a timed interval vs the set feed rate

Delivered volume well below the set rate

Lost pump delivery: prime, valves, suction, injection point

Day tank level change vs the product use expected from the feed log

Tank falls slower than the log says

Pump not delivering, or feed set lower than recorded

Bleed valve position, conductivity set point, makeup and blowdown meter totals

Lower cycles, or flow-based cycles more than 10 percent above conductivity cycles (US EPA, 2012)

Higher blowdown, leak or overflow diluting the product

Filtered vs unfiltered sample on the same meter

Filtered sample reads clearly higher

Color or turbidity suppression (Pyxis Lab, 2016)

Spike of a PTSA standard into tower water vs the same spike in deionized water

Recovery well below the deionized result

Matrix suppression: color, turbidity or cationic chemistry

PTSA calibration standard read on the same meter and cell

Reads below its stated value

Fouled sample cell or drifted calibration

Wet-chemistry inhibitor result converted to product ppm vs PTSA-derived product ppm

Both low and in agreement

Real underfeed; PTSA is telling the truth

The drawdown row comes first. A drawdown times the volume the pump draws from a calibration column and compares it with the set feed rate. If the pump delivers its set volume and the tank level agrees, the cause sits in blowdown or in the reading, not in the feed.

Sample handling decides whether the interference and instrument rows can be trusted. Take the filtered and unfiltered readings from one grab sample within minutes, and spike with a standard of known PTSA content. Record the meter and sample cell used, so the next low reading is checked the same way.

How do you fix a low PTSA reading for each cause?

Fix a low PTSA reading at its cause, not by raising the PTSA set point: if the reading is suppressed, a higher set point overfeeds the product. Raise feed only after the drawdown test and a direct inhibitor test show that the product level in the water is low.

For lost delivery, restore prime and clean the foot valve and check valves. Isolate and depressurize the feed line and injection point under the site's lockout procedure before you clear the injection quill. Then repeat the drawdown until delivered volume matches the set rate. Handle the product and any cleaning of fittings as its SDS directs, wearing the PPE it names, and treat drained product under the site's chemical waste rules.

For higher blowdown, return the bleed valve and conductivity set point to the agreed values, find the leak or overflow, and let the tower settle before judging the reading again. Solenis notes that varying makeup conductivity and multiple water sources upset makeup-proportional feed (Solenis, 2018); a site with those conditions may need feed paced on the tracer itself.

For interference, filter samples for handheld checks, use a color- and turbidity-compensating fluorometer, and suspend PTSA-based automatic dosing during quat biocide slug feeds (Pyxis Lab, 2016). For the ratio problem, enter the product's PTSA content in the meter's conversion table.

To prevent a repeat, log drawdowns, tank levels and cycles with every PTSA reading.

How do you confirm a PTSA reading against a direct inhibitor test?

Measure an active component of the product, such as total phosphate, molybdate or polymer, convert it to product ppm, and compare it with the product ppm the PTSA reading implies. Field verification trials used exactly these comparisons (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

Take both from the same water at the same time and convert with the supplier's product composition. Three outcomes are possible. If both are low and agree, the product is underfed and PTSA is right. If PTSA is low but the inhibitor test is on target, suspect the reading and run the filtered sample and spike checks. If PTSA is on target but the inhibitor is low, the system is consuming inhibitor under stress. Pyxis suggests that the gap between online PTSA and a wet-chemistry polymer or phosphate result can indicate system deposition stress (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

Before the check, verify the meter against its calibration standard; a handheld unit lists calibration points of 0, 100, 200 and 300 ppb PTSA (Pyxis Lab, n.d.). The direct test is the basis for any claim that the product itself is weak, the question covered in how to show whether a product complaint is really the product. For feed without tracer control, Walchem describes a manual inhibitor measurement during a monthly service call as the only way to know the tower is treated correctly (Walchem, 2020).

When should you call your water treatment supplier about low PTSA?

Call your water treatment supplier when the PTSA reading stays low after the pump delivers its set volume, blowdown is back at its set point and a filtered sample confirms the value. By then the remaining causes are the product, the conversion ratio or a matrix problem that needs the supplier's data.

Call at once, without waiting for that sequence, if a direct inhibitor test is also low and the system shows scale or corrosion signs, or if the inhibitor is low while PTSA is normal, which points to an upset consuming inhibitor (Walchem, 2020). Ask the supplier for the product's PTSA content, the expected product ppm at your set point, and the inhibitor test method and conversion they use, so both sides compare the same numbers.

Bring the records: PTSA trend, drawdown results, tank levels, makeup and blowdown totals, conductivity, any quat or cationic polymer use, and the direct inhibitor results with dates. In Lubinpla, a performance evaluation ties each PTSA and inhibitor result to its sample and method, judges first whether the readings are valid, and then separates what feed, blowdown or interference explains from a product problem.

Frequently asked questions

Does chlorine or bromine lower a PTSA reading?

Chlorine and bromine at normal cooling water dosage do not lower a PTSA reading. A patent result cited by Pyxis shows no PTSA decline over 24 hours with 1 ppm chlorine or stabilized bromine in simulated cooling water (Pyxis Lab, 2016). Ozone is different: PTSA has been reported to be destroyed in ozone treatment.

Why does the PTSA trend dip sharply and then recover?

A sharp dip that recovers usually marks a slug feed of quaternary amine biocide or bio-dispersant, which suppresses the PTSA reading (Pyxis Lab, 2016). Pyxis recommends temporarily disabling automatic dosing on PTSA feedback during the slug feed, so the controller does not overfeed product.

Can makeup water raise the PTSA reading instead?

Makeup water can add a small positive background. A survey of 24 cooling waters with surface water makeup found no sample above 10 ppb background PTSA, and process leaks of oil or organics can also fluoresce at the PTSA wavelengths (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

Can PTSA be used to trace boiler treatment?

PTSA is not suitable as a boiler tracer, because it hydrolyzes at high pH and elevated temperature (Pyxis Lab, 2016).

Related posts