Lubinpla

Why white rust comes back after cooling tower passivation

Summary

White rust usually returns on a passivated galvanized cooling tower after incomplete passivation, high pH or alkalinity, soft makeup water, or a chlorine, cleaning or inhibitor upset. Compare the original passivation record with today's water on each axis. A record that missed its targets points to recurrence; a record that met them points to a new upset.

  • Chem-Aqua recommends tower water pH between 7.0 and 8.2 for the first 8 weeks of operation, with hardness and M-alkalinity held between 50 and 300 ppm (Chem-Aqua, 2021).

  • A free chlorine spike above 1.0 mg/l that lasts more than 4 hours during passivation means the passivation process should be started over (Kurita America, 2021).

  • Carbonate ion first appears at a pH of about 8.4 and its concentration rises exponentially between pH 8.4 and 9.0 (Bond Water Technologies, 2022).

  • Re-passivation may be necessary after pH or oxidizer excursions, after disinfections, and when white rust becomes visible (Chem-Aqua, n.d.).

This applies to hot-dip galvanized steel towers, basins and coils in open recirculating cooling systems. It does not cover stainless steel, fiberglass or barrier-coated towers, or zinc lost to mechanical damage. Whether a deposit is white rust at all is settled by a lab analysis, not by this comparison.

What does white rust coming back after passivation look like?

Returning white rust shows up as new white, waxy or bumpy deposits on galvanized surfaces that had already turned the dull gray of a passivated coating. Chem-Aqua describes white rust as a yellowish to white, voluminous, porous deposit, while properly passivated galvanized surfaces have a dull, gray appearance (Chem-Aqua, 2021). Kurita America describes white spots and bumps made of zinc carbonate and zinc hydroxide that are porous and generally do not protect the steel (Kurita America, 2021). The protective film is least certain to form in continuously wetted areas such as the tower basin (Chem-Aqua, 2021).

Confirm the deposit before you call it a recurrence. White rust bubbles in acid because it contains carbonate, but calcium carbonate deposits do too, so Chem-Aqua recommends having a sample analyzed; significant zinc and carbonate in the deposit confirm white rust (Chem-Aqua, 2021).

Then record how far the damage has gone. Reddish rust spots inside white patches mean the zinc layer has broken and the underlying steel is corroding (Chem-Aqua, 2021). Under the bumps, corrosion of the base steel can concentrate into pitting, and Kurita America reports that basin leaks can form in as little as two months in severe cases (Kurita America, 2021). Photograph the same spots at every inspection, so later comparisons have a baseline.

What are the most likely causes of white rust returning after passivation?

The most likely causes of white rust returning after passivation fall into four groups: a first passivation that never finished; drift in pH and alkalinity; soft or changed makeup water; and oxidizer, cleaning or inhibitor upsets that strip a film that did form.

Incomplete first passivation of the galvanized tower

A passivation that started late, ran short or ran under full heat load can leave a film that does not hold. Kurita America warns that waiting even a week after water circulation starts will likely result in an incomplete passivation (Kurita America, 2021).

pH and alkalinity drift in the tower water

Chem-Aqua lists tower water pH above 8.3 or below 6.0 as a white rust factor (Chem-Aqua, 2021). Carbonate ion, the driver of white rust, rises steeply between pH 8.4 and 9.0 (Bond Water Technologies, 2022).

Soft or changed makeup water

Softened water or calcium below 50 ppm is a listed factor (Chem-Aqua, 2021), and so is changing makeup water quality (Chem-Aqua, n.d.).

Oxidizer, cleaning or inhibitor upsets

During passivation, free chlorine spikes above 1.0 mg/l can remove the passivation layer, and overfeed of phosphonates and chelating polymers can strip it (Kurita America, 2021).

How do you tell recurring white rust from a new cause on a galvanized tower?

You tell recurring white rust from a new cause by setting the original passivation record beside the current water analysis, axis by axis, and seeing which side was out of range. A first passivation that missed its targets never built a durable film, so the white rust is a recurrence. A record that met its targets, followed by a change in the water or an upset, points to a new cause that stripped a working film.

The table below sorts each axis toward one of the two answers.

Check

Passivation record vs now

Points to

Tower pH

Record outside 7.0 to 8.2 in the first 8 weeks (Chem-Aqua, 2021)

Incomplete first passivation

Tower pH

Record in range; now climbing toward 9.0, the post-passivation ceiling (Kurita America, 2021)

New cause: pH drift

M-alkalinity and hardness

Record outside 50 to 300 ppm (Chem-Aqua, 2021)

Incomplete first passivation

Calcium hardness

Record above 50 ppm; now lower after a softener or new supply, with no white rust inhibitor program (Chem-Aqua, 2021; Kurita America, 2021)

New cause: soft makeup water

Weeks held in passivation chemistry

Shorter than the program target, such as 8 to 12 weeks (Chem-Aqua, n.d.)

Incomplete first passivation

Disinfection or chlorine spike

Above 1.0 mg/l for more than 4 hours during passivation, not restarted (Kurita America, 2021)

Incomplete first passivation

Disinfection, acid or alkaline cleaning

Since passivation, tower not bypassed, cleaning pH below 6 or above 8 (Chem-Aqua, 2021)

New cause: stripped film

Makeup water source

Changed since passivation (Chem-Aqua, n.d.)

New cause: makeup change

Inhibitor residual

Phosphonate or chelating polymer overfed since passivation (Kurita America, 2021)

New cause: stripped film

Start with tower pH, because carbonate, the driver of white rust, rises steeply above pH 8.4 (Bond Water Technologies, 2022). A record that stayed inside 7.0 to 8.2 for the full first 8 weeks, with pH now drifting toward 9.0, points to a new cause, not a failed first passivation. Where the record is missing, treat the first passivation as unverified. The same method, applied to recurring problems in general, is set out in Recurring problem or new one: how to tell the difference.

Was the original cooling tower passivation incomplete?

The original passivation was probably incomplete if the record shows a late start, a short hold, out-of-range chemistry, or an oxidizer spike with no restart after it. Before judging, pull the startup water logs, the treatment provider's service reports and the commissioning dates.

Check four things in the record. First, the start: Kurita America warns that waiting even a week after water circulation starts will likely result in an incomplete passivation (Kurita America, 2021). Second, the duration: Chem-Aqua says passivation chemistry must be strictly maintained for at least the initial 8 to 12 weeks (Chem-Aqua, n.d.), Kurita America gives 12 to 14 weeks (Kurita America, 2021), and a manufacturer program with factory pretreatment usually lasts 4 to 8 weeks (Hoffman & Hoffman, 2020). Judge the record against the target of the program that was actually used. Third, the chemistry: for best pretreatment results Chem-Aqua says at least 100 ppm calcium hardness should normally be present (Chem-Aqua, 2021), and Kurita America requires a minimum of 50 to 100 mg/l calcium hardness as CaCO3 (Kurita America, 2021). Fourth, the end point: Kurita America treats passivation as concluded once a dull gray coating is visible on the galvanized metal (Kurita America, 2021).

A tower that never reached the dull gray finish, or reached it only in places, did not finish passivating.

Which pH and alkalinity swings break down the passive film on a galvanized tower?

Three kinds of swing break down the passive film on a galvanized tower: a rise toward pH 9.0, a drop below about pH 6.0, and alkalinity or hardness moving outside its window. Each bulletin cited here states its limit under its own conditions, so read every limit together with its condition.

High pH is the main threat after startup. Carbonate ion first appears at a pH of about 8.4 and rises exponentially between 8.4 and 9.0 (Bond Water Technologies, 2022). After a successful passivation, Kurita America allows tower pH to be increased slowly if necessary but never above 9.0 (Kurita America, 2021). Where makeup water is already near pH 8.2, as one bulletin reports for many supplies in its region, the tower can pass 8.4 after only modest cycling (Bond Water Technologies, 2022).

Low pH is the opposite risk. Chem-Aqua warns that even momentary low pH excursions can damage the galvanized coating when acid feed is used (Chem-Aqua, 2021), and lists tower water pH below 6.0 as a white rust factor (Chem-Aqua, 2021).

Alkalinity and hardness matter as well. Chem-Aqua sets tower water hardness and M-alkalinity between 50 and 300 ppm during the first eight weeks (Chem-Aqua, 2021). One 2021 trade article lists calcium below 50 ppm as CaCO3 and M-alkalinity above 300 ppm as conditions that contribute to white rust (Buecker and Kalakodimi, 2021). Replacing calcium with sodium through softening makes the water more corrosive to zinc (Keister, 2017).

When does a galvanized cooling tower need re-passivation?

Chem-Aqua says a galvanized cooling tower needs re-passivation after a pH or oxidizer excursion, after a disinfection, and when white rust becomes visible (Chem-Aqua, n.d.). Kurita America adds two triggers: a free chlorine spike above 1.0 mg/l lasting more than 4 hours during passivation, which means starting over, and overfeed of phosphonates or chelating polymers, which can remove the passivation and require a new passivation procedure (Kurita America, 2021).

On a tower that already has white rust, re-passivation is not guaranteed to work. Chem-Aqua says that once white rust has developed it may be difficult to stop in alkaline pH conditions, and that short-term pH reduction with acid and re-passivation can be tried but may not work in all cases (Chem-Aqua, 2021).

Plan it like the first passivation, with the treatment provider: clean off loose deposits without wire brushes or hard-edged tools, which Chem-Aqua warns could scratch the zinc coating (Chem-Aqua, 2021), return to the startup pH, hardness and alkalinity window, hold it for the program's full duration, and log every reading. If the plan uses acid for pH control, Kurita America says not to feed acid without real-time pH monitoring and control (Kurita America, 2021); handle the acid under its Safety Data Sheet (SDS) and your site's hazardous chemical rules. Kurita America says passivation is best accomplished under reduced heat load and that reduced cycles can increase the likelihood of success (Kurita America, 2021), so schedule it for a low-load season where you can.

When should you call a water treatment specialist about white rust?

Call a water treatment specialist about white rust when reddish rust shows through the white deposits, when white rust returns after a re-passivation, when there is no passivation record to compare against, or when the fix would need acid feed you cannot monitor in real time. In each case the base steel may already be at risk, or the next step carries a chemical hazard.

Bring the specialist what the comparison needs: the original passivation logs and dates, the last 12 months of tower and makeup water analyses, the disinfection and cleaning history, any change of makeup source or softener, the inhibitor program and feed records, and dated photographs of the same spots. If no deposit analysis for zinc and carbonate has been done, ask for one (Chem-Aqua, 2021).

Also ask whether galvanized steel still fits the site. Chem-Aqua notes that, due to water chemistry limits, there are no solutions that can absolutely guarantee prevention of white rust (Chem-Aqua, 2021), and Kurita America names plastic, stainless steel, concrete, wood and fiberglass as alternatives where the water requirements cannot be met (Kurita America, 2021).

Lubinpla works a case like this from your own passivation records and water analyses: it compares the earlier passivation conditions with the current water axis by axis and returns one cited document for your review, stating whether the evidence points to a recurrence or that no applicable precedent exists.

Frequently asked questions

Can white rust be removed from a galvanized cooling tower for good?

Not reliably. Chem-Aqua says that once white rust has developed it may be difficult to stop in alkaline pH conditions, and that short-term pH reduction and re-passivation can be tried but may not work in all cases (Chem-Aqua, 2021). Inspect the same areas after each attempt.

Does a factory pretreatment on new galvanized coils prevent white rust coming back?

It reduces the risk but does not replace field passivation. One manufacturer's factory pretreatment does not provide a completely passivated coil; it makes field passivation faster and yields better results (Hoffman & Hoffman, 2020). Recurrence is still decided by the field passivation record.

Can a passivated galvanized tower run on softened water?

Yes, with one condition. Kurita America says soft water is acceptable after a successful passivation, as long as a corrosion-inhibiting chemical program designed for white rust prevention is used (Kurita America, 2021). During passivation itself, though, softened water prevents the film from forming.

What are the options if white rust keeps returning on a galvanized tower?

Barrier coatings and other materials. Chem-Aqua names stainless steel basins and epoxy or rubber-based coatings (Chem-Aqua, 2021), and a water treatment bulletin notes that periodic recoating of tower sumps is an option for owners (Bond Water Technologies, 2022).

Related posts