Lubinpla

Why cooling tower cycles of concentration drop: control or makeup

Summary

Falling cooling tower cycles of concentration usually come from excess blowdown, a drifting conductivity controller, a makeup water quality change, or leaks and overflow. To tell which, calculate cycles from conductivity, chloride, silica and the water meters on same-day samples. If all fall together, water is really leaving; if one disagrees, the measurement or the makeup changed.

  • Many cooling towers operate at 2 to 4 cycles of concentration, and raising cycles from 3 to 6 reduces makeup water by 20% (US EPA, 2012).

  • If cycles from the makeup and blowdown meters exceed cycles from conductivity by more than 10%, the tower might be losing water to a leak, overflow or excessive drift (US EPA, 2012).

  • Conductivity cycles become unreliable when makeup conductivity is below 100 µmhos, chloride cycles when makeup chloride is below 10 ppm, and silica cycles when makeup silica is below 4.0 ppm (Solenis, 2023).

  • Drift can vary from 0.05% to 0.2% of the flow through a cooling tower (US EPA, 2012).

This applies to open recirculating cooling towers with makeup and blowdown, controlled on conductivity or by meters. It does not cover closed loops, once-through cooling or towers on a zero-blowdown program, and it does not set the target cycles for your water, which depend on the treatment program.

What are the most likely causes of dropping cooling tower cycles?

Cycles of concentration count how many times evaporation has concentrated the dissolved ions of the makeup water in the tower. They usually drop for one of four reasons: excess blowdown, a conductivity controller or probe that has drifted, a change in makeup water quality, or unmetered losses such as leaks and overflow. Chem-Aqua defines bleed as the removal of any water from the system other than evaporation, intentional or not, and notes that both kinds control the cycles (Chem-Aqua, 2018).

Excess blowdown from the controller or valve

A blowdown valve stuck open, a bleed timer left running, or a setpoint lowered during an upset and never restored: each one removes more water than the target allows. The US Department of Energy advises checking the conductivity controller, the makeup fill valve and the blowdown valve when a tower is not near its target cycles (US DOE FEMP, 2026).

Controller or probe drift

When the probe reads tower conductivity high, the controller bleeds early. Real cycles fall while the display still shows the setpoint.

Makeup water quality change

The controller holds tower conductivity at a fixed setpoint. Makeup water with higher conductivity reaches that setpoint at fewer cycles.

Leaks, overflow and drift

Pump seal leaks, system leaks, overflow down the tower drain and drift are all unintentional bleed (Chem-Aqua, 2018). When those losses run high enough, cycles may fall below ideal, and water use and treatment cost become excessive as a result (Chem-Aqua, 2018).

Why do conductivity, chloride and calcium cycles disagree in a cooling tower?

Conductivity, chloride and calcium cycles disagree when something other than evaporation adds or removes one of them: scale removes calcium and lowers conductivity, oxidizing biocides add chloride, and low makeup values magnify test error. In theory every dissolved ion is concentrated by the same factor, but Solenis notes that in reality this may not be the case (Solenis, 2023).

The table maps each pattern to the cause it points to. Calculate every value from tower and makeup samples taken the same day.

Check

What you see

Points to

All cycle values

Conductivity, chloride, silica and meter cycles all fall together

Real water loss: blowdown, leak or overflow

Conductivity vs chloride and silica

Conductivity cycles fall while chloride and silica hold

Scale lowering tower conductivity (Solenis, 2023)

Calcium vs the rest

Calcium cycles well below chloride, silica or magnesium cycles

Calcium precipitating as scale (Solenis, 2023)

Chloride under bleach or bromine

Chloride cycles above conductivity and silica cycles

Oxidizing biocide adding chloride (Solenis, 2023)

Makeup conductivity

Higher than when the setpoint was set

Same setpoint, fewer cycles

Meter ratio vs conductivity ratio

Meter cycles more than 10% above conductivity cycles (US EPA, 2012)

Leak, overflow or excessive drift

Controller vs handheld meter

Controller reads tower conductivity higher than a handheld check

Probe drift causing early bleed

Basin at idle

Water running to the overflow drain

Unmetered overflow

The second row changes the action most. When conductivity cycles drop while chloride and silica cycles hold, the water is not leaving faster; calcium salts are likely precipitating.

In one published power plant case, precipitating hardness lowered the conductivity, so the controller decreased bleed-off and the water cycled up even more (Buckman, 2013). There, conductivity gave 4.3 cycles and calcium 3.4, while magnesium gave 6.8 and silica 7.8 (Buckman, 2013).

Which ion should you use to calculate cooling tower cycles?

Use the ion whose makeup level is high enough to measure accurately and that nothing but evaporation adds or removes; conductivity, chloride or silica are the usual choices (Chem-Aqua, 2018). Choose this reference before you read the trend and write the choice down. Do not switch ions mid-trend: the change of ion would look like a change in cycles.

Each of the three fails under certain conditions, and Solenis lists them (Solenis, 2023). Conductivity is usually a good indicator except where makeup conductivity is below 100 µmhos, where calcium carbonate scale is likely, where large amounts of sulfuric acid are fed, or where large amounts of bleach are used. Chloride can be a good indicator except where makeup chloride is below 10 ppm or oxidizing biocides are used. Silica can be a good indicator except where makeup silica is below 4.0 ppm or silica precipitation is a concern.

Calcium is the check, not the reference. Chem-Aqua recommends periodically comparing calculated cycles with cycles based on hardness to make sure scaling is controlled (Chem-Aqua, 2018). Solenis calls this the calcium balance: if calcium is precipitating, the calcium cycles fall well below the best estimate of actual cycles (Solenis, 2023).

Where makeup quality swings often, the meters may be the only practical measure: cycles equal makeup volume divided by blowdown volume, which is accurate only if all blowdown is metered (Solenis, 2023).

How does a change in makeup water change the cycles reading?

The reading moves because cycles by conductivity are tower conductivity divided by makeup conductivity (US EPA, 2012), while the controller holds the tower side at a fixed setpoint. Raise the makeup value and the same setpoint now means fewer cycles; lower it and the same setpoint means more.

Take an illustrative case: a controller set at 1,500 µS/cm on makeup at 300 µS/cm runs about 5 cycles. If the supply changes to 400 µS/cm, the same setpoint gives about 3.75 cycles, with more blowdown and more makeup, though nothing on the tower has failed (illustrative values).

The reverse also happens: one water treatment company reports a tower running at nearly 9 cycles against a 4 to 5 cycle program after a utility changed its treatment and nobody updated the setpoint (ChemReady, 2026).

Two reading errors look like the same drop. If the makeup sample comes from a different day than the tower sample, during a supply swing, the ratio matches neither condition. A makeup analysis carried forward from an old report keeps dividing by a value that is no longer true.

So before reading a cycles trend, fix the conversion rule: which ion, which makeup sample and which date. Rising customer complaints: product quality vs better logging applies the same discipline of separating a real change from a change in how it is measured.

How do you find leaks and overflow that lower cooling tower cycles?

Find leaks and overflow by comparing meter cycles with conductivity cycles, then walking the system for unmetered losses. The US EPA notes that if cycles from the makeup and blowdown meters are higher than cycles from conductivity by more than 10%, the tower might be losing water to a leak, overflow or excessive drift (US EPA, 2012).

Work through the losses in order:

  1. Read the makeup and blowdown meters over the same period and calculate meter cycles. If both ratios are not about the same, the US Department of Energy says to check the tower for leaks or other unauthorized draw-off (US DOE FEMP, 2026).

  2. Check the float or fill valve. The US EPA advises making sure the fill valve cuts off cleanly when the basin is full (US EPA, 2012), and the US Department of Energy advises checking float control equipment so the basin level is maintained properly (US DOE FEMP, 2026).

  3. Watch the overflow drain at idle and at shutdown, when water draining back from piping can raise the basin level.

  4. Inspect pump seals and piping. Chem-Aqua lists pump seal losses, system leaks, overflow down the tower drain and drift as unintentional bleed (Chem-Aqua, 2018).

  5. Inspect drift eliminators. Drift can vary from 0.05% to 0.2% of the tower flow (US EPA, 2012).

Log makeup, blowdown, conductivity and cycles so that the trend shows when the losses started (US EPA, 2012).

When should you call a water treatment specialist about low cycles?

Call a water treatment specialist when the ion cycles disagree and you cannot tell which one is right, when calcium cycles fall below the others, when the makeup supply or its treatment has changed, or when cycles stay low after the valves, float and meters check out. Low cycles cost water and chemical, and Chem-Aqua warns that most corrosion inhibitor programs work only if the specified cycles are maintained (Chem-Aqua, 2018).

Bring the specialist a dated set of numbers: tower and makeup conductivity, chloride, silica, calcium and magnesium from same-day samples; makeup and blowdown meter readings; the controller setpoint and its last calibration; any change to biocide, acid feed or makeup source; and the dates the drop started.

Ask which value the program uses as the reference for cycles and whether the setpoint still matches the current makeup.

Lubinpla works a case like this from your own water analyses and controller logs: it fixes which value the cycles are calculated from before looking at the results, then reads the change signal and returns one cited document for your review.

Frequently asked questions

What is a normal number of cycles of concentration for a cooling tower?

Many systems operate at 2 to 4 cycles of concentration, while 6 cycles or more may be possible, depending on makeup water quality and the treatment program (US EPA, 2012). The right target for a given tower comes from its makeup analysis and the program's limits.

Do low cycles damage a cooling tower?

They can. Chem-Aqua notes that most corrosion inhibitor programs are designed to give effective control only if the specified cycles are maintained, so failure to maintain them can result in severe corrosion and scale, besides higher water and treatment use (Chem-Aqua, 2018).

Does bleach feed change the cycles reading?

Yes. Large amounts of bleach can make tower conductivity much higher than the true cycles, and chlorine and bromine compounds can significantly increase the measured chloride, especially where makeup values are low (Solenis, 2023). Silica may then be the better reference.

Can cycles be measured without chemical tests?

Yes, with meters. Cycles equal makeup volume divided by blowdown volume over the same period, and this is accurate only if all blowdown, including overflow and leaks, passes through the meter (Solenis, 2023).

Related posts