Lubinpla

How to show a water treatment chemical caused the results

Summary

Crediting a water treatment chemical takes four steps: fix a baseline, match comparison periods, adjust for makeup water and load, and credit only what remains. That remainder belongs to the chemical when nothing else changed at start, such as a heat exchanger cleaning, and when direct evidence in the treated water, such as corrosion coupons, moves the same way.

  • U.S. federal measurement and verification guidance calculates savings as baseline use minus post-installation use, plus or minus adjustments for changes unrelated to the measure, such as weather or occupancy (U.S. DOE FEMP, 2015).

  • In a federal cooling tower case, water and electricity for eight months of 2009 were compared with the same months of 2008, while cycles rose from 2.5 to 5.7 and three heat exchangers, cleaned off site by the new system during a demonstration, had been reinstalled before startup (U.S. DOE FEMP, 2011).

  • ASTM D2688 measures corrosion rate in a water system by coupon weight loss without heat transfer, and its significance section names the evaluation of corrosion inhibitors as one use (ASTM D2688, 2023).

  • ASTM D5465 sets uniform procedures for counting colonies and reporting colony-forming units from membrane filters and pour and spread plates (ASTM D5465, 2025).

This method is written for open recirculating cooling water systems. Boiler and wastewater programs follow the same logic with different direct measurements. Legionella risk management runs under its own water management program, not as a performance claim.

What baseline do you need before a water treatment program starts?

Before a water treatment program starts, you need a baseline record that matches the comparison period in season and length, taken under known operating conditions, with direct water measurements next to the utility totals. Guidance under the International Performance Measurement and Verification Protocol (IPMVP) says the baseline period should represent a normal operating cycle and include only periods for which the energy-governing facts about the facility are known (EVO, IPMVP Core Concepts review copy).

For a cooling tower, record six things before the new program starts:

  1. Makeup and blowdown volumes from meters, plus the cycles of concentration: the conductivity of blowdown divided by the conductivity of makeup water.

  2. Makeup water quality: conductivity, hardness, alkalinity and silica.

  3. Heat load: chiller or process run hours and load, logged alongside the water data.

  4. Corrosion coupon rates under the old program, measured by ASTM D2688.

  5. Microbial counts, with the method used to report them.

  6. Heat exchanger condition: approach temperatures and an inspection note on deposits.

The U.S. Federal Energy Management Program (FEMP) recommends flow meters on makeup and blowdown lines and a log of makeup and blowdown quantities, conductivity and cycles of concentration (U.S. DOE FEMP, Best Management Practice #10). Its NASA Marshall case follows the same practice: before the change, the site collected electricity, water and sewer data to set a baseline and tested both the cooling system water and the raw water (U.S. DOE FEMP, 2011).

How do you separate makeup water, load and operating changes from the chemical's effect?

Adjust the baseline to the conditions of the comparison period, then credit the chemical with only what is left. FEMP measurement and verification guidance states that proper determination of savings includes adjusting for changes that affect use but are unrelated to equipment performance, such as weather, occupancy or other factors (U.S. DOE FEMP, 2015).

For any water saving, check cycles of concentration first, because they set makeup and blowdown directly. FEMP states that increasing cycles from three to six reduces cooling tower makeup water by 20% and blowdown by 50% (U.S. DOE FEMP, Best Management Practice #10). If a program raised cycles, the water it saved came from the blowdown set point. The chemical's share is narrower: it kept scale and corrosion under control at the higher cycles, and that share shows in coupons and deposits, not in the water bill.

Load and weather come next. Compare the same months, and express water and energy per unit of heat rejected, for example makeup volume per chiller run hour (illustrative unit). Makeup water quality matters as well, since a softer or lower-silica source allows higher cycles on its own.

Mechanical work at program start, such as a cleaning or a repair, is a one-time change and needs its own calculation. IPMVP calls these non-routine adjustments, individually engineered calculations for changes in factors not expected to change (EVO, IPMVP Core Concepts review copy).

Which measurements show the water treatment chemical itself worked?

The measurements that show the chemical itself worked are taken in the treated water and on the metal it protects: corrosion coupons, microbial counts, deposit inspection and the product residual, which is the measured amount of product left in the system water. Utility totals show that something changed. These measurements show what the chemical did.

  • Corrosion coupons by ASTM D2688. The method states that the corrosion rate of a material in water "is determined in relative, rather than absolute, terms" (ASTM D2688, 2023). So compare coupons of the same alloy, at the same rack position and exposure time, before and after the change.

  • Microbial counts reported to ASTM D5465, which gives uniform counting, calculating and reporting procedures for colony counts (ASTM D5465, 2025). Keep the sampling point and the method the same in both periods.

  • Deposit and fouling evidence: heat exchanger approach temperatures at comparable load, and inspection of tubes and fill.

  • Product residual and dosing records: the measured residual in the system water stays in its target range, and the volume fed matches makeup water and the dosing plan.

The residual record is what ties the chemical to the result. If the residual sat below target during the weeks a coupon improved, that improvement cannot be credited to the chemical, because the chemical was not present at its working level. Read all four records together for the same dates.

How do you check a water treatment program result before crediting the chemical?

Before crediting the chemical, test each claimed improvement against its confounders, meaning the other changes such as cycles, load or a cleaning that could explain it, one row at a time. Only then decide the share of credit. A creditable result needs a baseline, matched conditions, no one-time changes at the start, and direct evidence that agrees with the utility totals.

The check table below decides whether the chemical earns credit in full, in part, or not at all.

Check

Pass

Fail and what to do

Baseline period

Same season and same length as the comparison period

Different season: re-pick the baseline or adjust for weather, then recheck

Cycles and makeup water

Cycles and makeup quality unchanged, or adjusted; from three to six cycles cuts makeup by 20% (U.S. DOE FEMP, Best Management Practice #10)

Cycles raised: credit the water saving to cycles, judge the chemical on coupons and deposits

Heat load and run hours

Comparable load, or results expressed per unit of load

Load fell: normalize before crediting anything

Cleaning or repair at start

None in the 3 months before or after start (illustrative window)

Cleaning done: treat it as a non-routine adjustment, credit only later trends

Dosing and residual

Residual in target range on the dates of the result

Residual off target: no credit for that period

Corrosion coupon rate

Lower than the baseline rate for the same alloy (ASTM D2688, 2023)

Same or higher: no corrosion credit, investigate dose and water chemistry

The cycles row decides most water-saving claims. When cycles rose, the water saved belongs to the blowdown set point, and the chemical earns credit only for coupon and deposit results at the new cycles.

Record a verdict and its reason for each row, then read the rows together:

  • Full credit fits when every row passes.

  • Partial credit fits when the coupon, deposit and residual rows pass but cycles, load or a cleaning explain part of the utility saving.

  • No credit fits when the residual or coupon row fails.

What can a water treatment program result never prove on its own?

A program result can never prove, on its own, that the chemical caused an improvement when the comparison has no adjustment for what else changed. A before-and-after comparison shows that something changed. It does not show which change did it.

The NASA Marshall cooling loop case in FEMP's series shows the limit. There, a new treatment platform using radio frequency scale control, ozone and side-stream filtration replaced chemical treatment. Water and electricity for eight months of 2009 were compared with the same months of 2008, a matched-season comparison (U.S. DOE FEMP, 2011). The loop saved about 3,100 m3 (821,300 gallons) of water against a projection of about 1,600 m3 (420,808 gallons) (U.S. DOE FEMP, 2011). The case reports heat exchanger operating temperatures lowered by about 3 °C (5 to 6 °F) (U.S. DOE FEMP, 2011).

Two other changes came with the platform. In the same changeover, cycles of concentration rose from 2.5 to 5.7, and three of six heat exchangers, cleaned off site by the new system during a 90-day demonstration, were reinstalled before the platform started in service (U.S. DOE FEMP, 2011). The case study reports these outcomes together and does not separate the cleaning, the higher cycles and the treatment from each other.

The same separation works in reverse when a customer says a product stopped working, as covered in how to show whether a product complaint is about the product. Either way, a claim holds only for the part the evidence can carry.

When should you get an independent review of a water treatment program result?

Get an independent review when the credit will be used in a contract, a renewal or a published case, or when more than one change happened at program start. A reviewer who did not run the program reads the baseline, the adjustments and the direct evidence with no stake in the answer.

Give the reviewer the baseline records, the meter and conductivity logs for both periods, the coupon reports with alloy and exposure days, the microbial results with method, the dosing and residual logs, and a dated list of all mechanical work. Ask for three outputs: the performance status of the system, the share that can be credited to the chemical, and what cannot be decided from the evidence.

Lubinpla, an applied AI company for specialty chemical technical work, judges the performance status and the share credited to the product as separate findings, and cites the project's recorded conditions and product use records. An engineer familiar with the plant should still confirm any adjustment that rests on an engineering estimate, such as the effect of a cleaning.

Frequently asked questions

How long should the baseline period be for a cooling tower program?

A cooling tower baseline should cover at least the season the result will be compared with, and ideally a full operating year, so that both warm and cool months are in the record. IPMVP guidance asks for a baseline that spans a full operating cycle from maximum to minimum use (EVO, IPMVP Core Concepts review copy).

Can a treatment supplier's own report show the chemical worked?

A supplier's own report can show the chemical worked if it includes the baseline, the adjustments, the coupon and residual data and the list of other changes, so that a third party can repeat the calculation. A report with only before-and-after totals cannot separate the chemical from cycles, load or cleaning.

Do lower utility bills prove the water treatment program works?

Lower utility bills do not prove the program works, because water and sewer charges fall whenever blowdown falls, whatever the cause. A water bill measures volume. The chemical's own effect shows in corrosion, deposit and microbial results in the treated water.

Related posts